Last Updated on November 9, 2026 by Karl Thompson
Private companies have always had a hand in state education: textbook publishers shaped what was taught long before computers arrived. Digital technology has expanded that role enormously. Global technology companies such as Google, Microsoft and Apple now supply the devices, software and online platforms that much day-to-day teaching runs on, alongside thousands of smaller education technology (‘ed-tech’) start-ups.
This post summarises the sociologist Neil Selwyn’s account of what these companies offer education, the Silicon Valley mindset behind them, and the problems he sees in their growing influence. It’s useful for answers on the privatisation of education and on neoliberal perspectives on education, for AQA A-level Sociology Paper 1 (7192/1).
Why this is privatisation
Stephen Ball and Deborah Youdell distinguish two kinds of privatisation in education. Endogenous privatisation is privatisation in public education: business methods brought inside state schools. Exogenous privatisation is privatisation of public education: private companies taking over the design, management or delivery of parts of the service, for profit.
The growing role of technology companies is exogenous privatisation. Schools are still publicly funded, but more and more of what happens in them runs on products and platforms owned by private companies. For the wider picture, see my post on neoliberalism and the privatisation of education.
Digital capitalism and education
Selwyn argues that digital technology gives private companies more potential to shape how public education is organised and delivered than they have ever had before. The reason is partly practical. National governments don’t develop digital technologies themselves, so it is large transnational companies that drive their development, and public education systems are one of the biggest potential markets for their products.
All the big technology companies have education divisions that develop software and applications for schools, and many other companies, from Pearson to Lego, sell educational products. At the other end of the scale are hundreds, if not thousands, of small ed-tech start-ups trying to get a foothold in the education market.
What technology companies claim to offer
Selwyn identifies three potential benefits of involving private technology companies in public education:
- Scale. Transnational companies have global reach and huge sums to invest, far beyond what any public sector organisation can match. They promise to make technology easy for schools to deploy and manage.
- Results. The private sector emphasises quick results and demonstrable outcomes, because companies are ultimately accountable to their shareholders.
- Innovation. The technology industry sees itself as bringing new products and new ideas into education. Its firms pride themselves on thinking big, acting quickly and taking risks, from an ‘outsider’ position free of the assumptions of the education establishment.
The Silicon Valley mindset
Sebastian Thrun, co-founder of the online learning company Udacity, put the industry’s view of education bluntly: “Education is broken. Face it. It is so broken at so many ends, it requires a little bit of Silicon Valley magic.”
Selwyn argues that this ‘Silicon Valley magic’ reflects a particular business culture. Many of the industry’s leading figures, such as Mark Zuckerberg, Larry Page, Sergey Brin and Peter Thiel, come from programming backgrounds. In Selwyn’s account, their companies are shaped by a faith in computing power, a relentless focus on invention, and a start-up culture in which most ventures fail quickly but investors keep backing the next ‘big thing’. The culture values entrepreneurialism, risk-taking, learning through failure and the power of individuals over institutions.
Selwyn also notes that many of these figures genuinely want to ‘make a difference’, using technology to tackle big social problems such as global health and poverty. Education is one of the areas where they most want to do so.
Thinking big, spending bigger
Technology companies and their founders influence education in several ways:
- Corporate education programmes. The large technology companies all run education programmes, often under the heading of ‘corporate social responsibility’: designing schools, training teachers, developing curricula and supplying hardware, software and infrastructure.
- Philanthropy. Mark Zuckerberg gave $100 million to schools in Newark, New Jersey, in 2010, and in 2014 he and Priscilla Chan pledged $120 million to schools in the San Francisco Bay Area. The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation has played a major part in US school reform, including standardised testing and the Common Core curriculum.
- Alternatives to education. Peter Thiel’s Thiel Fellowship offered young people $100,000 to leave college and build a business instead.
- Online courses. Companies such as Coursera, backed by venture capital, offer MOOCs (massive open online courses) to millions of learners.
- Soft power. The technology industry lobbied governments to put coding on the school curriculum, which is now widely accepted as a good thing.
Selwyn’s point is that corporate involvement in education is often hidden in complex networks of influence. If you follow the money, technology companies are involved in, and hope to profit from, most digital education initiatives. The most influential voices in debates about the future of education are increasingly programmers and technology executives rather than teachers.
Problems with technology companies in education
Technology companies and their supporters have made big claims, both about what is wrong with traditional public education and about what digital innovations such as MOOCs could do to fix it. Selwyn argues that many of these innovations have promised much and delivered far less. Technology companies may blame schools for failing to embrace their products, but Selwyn’s view is that the companies have failed to understand public education and how complicated it is to educate people.
He identifies four ways in which the values of Silicon Valley clash with the values of public education.

1. Education is not a computational project
Innovations such as online course platforms tend to treat education as a computational problem: a set of variables that can be adjusted and programmed to remove ‘bugs’ and inefficiencies. Selwyn argues that this is reductive. The social complexity of real classrooms can’t easily be built into an algorithm designed to make learning more efficient, and a computer can’t settle the moral questions about what students should be learning.
2. ‘Learning through failure’ doesn’t fit education
In Silicon Valley, most start-ups are expected to fail, and the few that survive go on to change the world. Selwyn argues that this ‘fail fast, fail often’ approach doesn’t translate to education, where the experiments are gambling with the futures of real students and schools. Bill Gates admitted as much about his foundation’s education work in 2013: “It would be great if our education stuff worked, but that we won’t know for probably a decade.”
This clashes with the social democratic ideal that education should support every learner to succeed.
3. Too much focus on the individual
Silicon Valley culture is rooted in a libertarian belief in personal freedom and individual action, and a scepticism towards experts working in traditional institutions such as schools. Innovations such as MOOCs and flipped classrooms grew out of this individualist philosophy.
Selwyn argues that this can undermine the social democratic values of public education, such as community cohesion, shared responsibility and the public good. It may also undermine equality of opportunity: Selwyn argues that MOOCs tend to attract people who are already well educated, many of whom already have degrees, rather than widening access.
4. A threat to democratic accountability
When the leaders of companies such as Google, Microsoft and Facebook speak about education, governments listen. The problem is that these companies help to shape education systems and profit from doing so, but nobody elected them and they aren’t accountable to the public in the way a government is. The educationalist Joel Spring makes a similar argument; see my summary of his book Education Networks: Power, Wealth, Cyberspace and the Digital Mind.
Conclusion
Technology companies are unlikely to stop trying to disrupt education, and governments that favour market solutions are unlikely to stop them. But the public is also unlikely to give up on the social democratic ideals of public education, so at some point the two approaches will have to be reconciled.
Using this in the exam
This material works as up-to-date evidence in answers on:
- privatisation: technology companies are a clear example of exogenous privatisation, alongside academy trusts, PFI and Pearson’s ownership of the Edexcel exam board
- neoliberal and New Right perspectives: the claimed benefits (scale, results, innovation) are the neoliberal case for private provision; Selwyn’s four problems are the case against
- evaluation from other perspectives: a Marxist would see technology companies turning public education into a source of profit; a social democratic critic would stress the loss of democratic accountability and the threat to equality of opportunity
In an essay, one or two sentences is usually enough: name the companies, say what they supply, and make one evaluative point, such as Selwyn’s argument about accountability.
Related posts
- Neoliberalism and the privatisation of education
- The neoliberal perspective on education
- Outline three ways in which schools have become increasingly privatised (6)
- Is digital technology good for education? (a summary of the first chapter of Selwyn’s book)
Sociology of Education Revision Bundle
If you like this sort of thing, then you might like my sociology of education revision notes bundle, written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.
Signposting
This post is part of the sociology of education module.
Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com
Sources
Gates, B. (2013) interview at Harvard University, 21 September, as reported in eSchool News, 27 September 2013.
Ball, S. and Youdell, D. (2007) Hidden Privatisation in Public Education, Education International.
Selwyn, N. (2016) Is Technology Good for Education? Cambridge: Polity.