To what extent is the family a willing unit of consumption?

Last Updated on November 19, 2026 by Karl Thompson

Contemporary Marxists argue that one of the main functions of the family in capitalist societies is to act as a ‘unit of consumption’ – the family unit is supposed to buy the products necessary to keep capitalism going.

Key to understanding this theory is the idea of ‘false needs’ – which in Marxist theory are perceived ‘needs’ created by the capitalist system, rather than our ‘real needs’.

‘Real needs’ are basic material things such as food, shelter and clothing, but we might also include transport, health, education and general welfare.

‘False needs’ arise because of the demands of the capitalist system, rather than what we as individuals need. They include such things as the need for distraction or anything else we ‘need’ to make life bearable in an unfair system, anything we might buy to give off a sense of our social status, and anything we buy or do to give ourselves or our children an edge in an artificially unequal world. We could also include many of the products we buy out of fear, or out of the need to make ourselves safe, if that fear is engineered by the capitalist system to keep the population under control.

This post has been written as part of an evaluation of The Marxist Perspective on the Family, part of the families and households module within A-level sociology.

Who said the family is a unit of consumption?

Eli Zaretsky

The idea that the family is a unit of consumption is most closely associated with the American Marxist Eli Zaretsky, in Capitalism, the Family and Personal Life (1976). Zaretsky argued that industrial capitalism separated work from home. Before industrialisation, the family was a unit of production; under capitalism it became a unit of consumption, buying the goods that capitalist industry produces.

Zaretsky also argued that the family appears to be a private refuge from the alienating world of paid work, a place where people can be themselves. But for Zaretsky this is an illusion: the family is tied to the economy, and its role as a refuge and as a consumer helps keep capitalism going.

Herbert Marcuse and ‘false needs’

The idea of ‘false needs’ comes from the German-American Marxist Herbert Marcuse, in One-Dimensional Man (1964). Marcuse argued that advanced capitalist societies create needs that people experience as their own, but which mainly serve the system: the need to keep buying, to keep up with others, and to find satisfaction in consumer goods. Because people feel these needs are genuine, they don’t see their own exploitation – which is why Marxists link false needs to ‘false consciousness’.

False needs and the family

It is possible to think of many examples of families making purchases and consuming stuff which could fall into the category of false needs, which ultimately serves the needs of the capitalist system. Examples could include:

  • Purchases parents make just to keep their kids quiet and simply give themselves time to manage their lives, given that parents do not have enough time at home because they both must work in a capitalist system. This could include toys and subscriptions to media entertainment packages.
  • Purchases parents make to give their children an advantage in education. In Marxist theory education reproduces class inequality, primarily because the middle classes can buy their kids a better education.
  • Purchases parents make to give their family a sense of status to the outside world – this could be for the family as a whole, such as a better car, or parents giving in to the demands for kids to have the latest status clothes or phone.
  • Products bought to keep kids ‘safe’, which could be mainly for younger children.
  • A lot of the above will be made worse by the ‘built-in obsolescence’ of many products.

Evidence of the family perpetuating false needs

This section looks at possible evidence that families buy things they don’t really need, giving in to false needs rather than consuming on the basis of real needs.

Some places we might look for evidence include:

  • Case studies of high-consumption families, but how representative are they?
  • Statistics on advertising expenditure aimed at families, and its effectiveness.
  • Statistics on family expenditure – trends in how much parents spend on children, and what parents actually buy.
  • Pester power – how often do parents give in to their kids’ nagging?
  • Counter studies – what does a family living in ‘real consciousness’ look like?

Keep in mind that there are limitations with all of the evidence below, and you can always use your own brain-thing to find your own examples!

My Super Sweet 16

Shows such as ‘My Super Sweet 16’ probably show us the most extreme examples of parents willingly meeting their children’s false needs. Charlie Brooker provides a good analysis of this in How TV Ruined Your Life (5.30 mins on).

The problem with such case studies is that they are maybe not that representative of families in America, let alone in the UK!

Pocket money and pester power

Companies know that children pester their parents for things they want, and so a good deal of advertising has historically been targeted at children. Children are also consumers in their own right: many receive pocket money, and spend it on consumer goods from games consoles to toys and books. Whether this is evidence of false needs being established from a young age is debatable – some purchases look like status goods, while others, such as Lego and books, seem quite educational.

Parental expenditure on education

One of the clearest examples of families spending to give their children an edge is private tutoring. According to the Sutton Trust’s 2026 polling, 29% of secondary school students in England and Wales have had private tutoring at some point, up from 18% when the survey began, rising to 45% in London. Students from better-off households are more likely to have had it than those from the worst-off households (30% compared with 23%) (Sutton Trust, 2026). A Marxist would read this as families using their spending power to reproduce class advantage.

Counter-evidence

Don’t forget to look for counter-evidence too. Governments have placed restrictions on companies’ power to advertise to children, which may reduce pester power. Sweden has banned television advertising aimed at children under 12 since 1991. In the UK, advertising to children is governed by the advertising codes, and since 5 January 2026 adverts for ‘less healthy’ food and drink have been banned on TV before 9pm and from paid-for online advertising (gov.uk). You could also look for examples of ‘frugal families’ who deliberately consume less.

Criticisms of the Marxist view of the family as a unit of consumption

Do parents really have ‘false’ needs?

Marxists assume that parents are under false consciousness, buying things they don’t need for their families and children, rather than making rational decisions about what to buy.

But some purchases that look like false needs may be genuine. Some of the safety products for babies may come into this category – maybe it is better to spend £400 on a super-safe buggy than to rely on your parents’ hand-me-downs? Who decides which needs are ‘real’ and which are ‘false’ is itself a problem for the theory.

Individuals might have more false needs than families

It’s also not clear that the family is the most significant unit of consumption. Young adults not yet in families are perfectly capable of buying things they don’t need themselves in their 20s and 30s, and it’s debatable whether their spending on ‘false need’ items is higher once they have families in their 30s, 40s and 50s.

How this comes up in the exam

The family as a unit of consumption is one of the main Marxist arguments you can use in the 20-mark essay on Marxist explanations of the family. AQA set this question in June 2022 – see Evaluate Marxist explanations of the role of families in society today (20 marks) for a full answer.

Signposting and related posts

For the wider Marxist view, see The Marxist Perspective on the Family. For how the family’s functions have changed from production to consumption, see What are the functions of the family today?

Leave a Reply

Turn on JavaScript to leave a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Exit mobile version
%%footer%%