Last Updated on November 7, 2026 by Karl Thompson
In-school factors are the things that happen inside schools which may explain gender differences in education. The main ones are:
- teacher expectations and labelling
- laddish subcultures and the fear of failure
- the feminisation of education
- changes in assessment, especially coursework
- the ways school still disadvantages girls, even though girls now get better results.
Most of the debate is about why girls outperform boys. But “gender inequality in education” is wider than the achievement gap: boys do worse in exams, while girls face problems at school that exam results don’t show. This post covers both sides.
In-school factors are usually contrasted with factors outside school, such as changes in women’s employment and in the family, which are covered on my post on explaining the gender gap in education. Both are part of the gender and education topic in the sociology of education module, examined on AQA Paper 1 (7192/1).
The gap these factors are trying to explain
Girls have outperformed boys at 16 since the late 1980s, but the gap is now smaller than many textbooks suggest. In England in 2025/26:
- the gap in the percentage of pupils achieving grade 5 or above in English and maths was 3.1 percentage points in girls’ favour
- girls’ average Attainment 8 score was 3.9 points higher than boys’, down from 5.5 points in 2018/19.
The gap between disadvantaged pupils and the rest on the same English and maths measure was 26.8 percentage points, nearly nine times larger. That is worth remembering when you evaluate any explanation of the gender gap: class matters far more than gender.
Teacher expectations and labelling
Interactionists argue that teachers’ expectations of pupils can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Pupils labelled as able and well-behaved are encouraged, and live up to the label; pupils labelled as troublemakers are disciplined more often, and may come to see themselves as the label says. The theory is explained on my post on labelling theory and the self-fulfilling prophecy. This section applies it to gender.
Applied to gender, the argument is that teachers expect girls to be quiet, organised and hard-working, and boys to be disruptive. In a review of the research for the Equal Opportunities Commission, Christine Skelton, Becky Francis and Yordanka Valkanova (2007) cite evidence that teachers’ judgements of boys’ academic abilities were informed by their behaviour. If a boy’s behaviour colours how his ability is judged, the label can affect his results as well as his conduct.
Behaviour is also where the difference between boys and girls is clearest in official statistics. In 2024/25 the permanent exclusion rate for boys in England was more than twice that for girls (0.16 against 0.07), and boys were suspended at more than one and a half times the rate of girls. Interactionists would argue that some of this reflects how boys’ behaviour is labelled and responded to, not just the behaviour itself. Exclusions are covered in more detail on my post on why some children get excluded from school.
HOWEVER, labelling doesn’t explain why the gap opened when it did. Teachers held stereotypes about boys and girls long before girls overtook boys in the late 1980s.
Laddish subcultures and the fear of failure
A pupil subculture is a group of pupils who share values that differ from the school’s (see my post on pupil subcultures). The best-known anti-school subculture is the “lads” in Paul Willis’s Learning to Labour (1977): working-class boys who rejected school and expected to go into manual work. Tony Sewell’s study of black boys and hyper-masculinity (1997) is covered on my post on Tony Sewell, and Máirtín Mac an Ghaill’s research on masculinities is covered on my post on gender identity and education.
Carolyn Jackson: lads, ladettes and the fear of failure
The most useful study on laddishness for this topic is Carolyn Jackson’s Lads and Ladettes in School: Gender and a Fear of Failure (2006). Jackson studied Year 9 pupils in eight secondary schools in the north of England, using questionnaires and interviews with more than 200 pupils and with their teachers.
Most pupils in her study saw working hard as uncool. Academic success only counted as cool if it looked effortless. Jackson’s explanation is that laddish behaviour protects pupils’ self-worth. If you mess about and don’t revise, and then do badly, you can blame lack of effort rather than lack of ability. If you do well anyway, you look effortlessly clever. Pupils in her study admitted lying about their marks and their effort, and leaving work until the last minute, so they would never be seen to fail after trying.
Two findings make Jackson useful in an exam.
First, laddishness was not just a boys’ thing. Jackson found girls behaving in laddish ways too, which suggests laddishness is a response to the pressure of constant testing, not simply part of being male.
Second, she explains the link between laddishness and achievement without blaming the pupils. Fear of failure, in a school system where everyone is constantly ranked, makes not trying a rational strategy for a pupil who is worried about looking stupid.
The feminisation of education
The feminisation of education is the argument that schools have become organised around qualities seen as feminine, such as neatness, organisation, sitting still and sustained written work, and that this disadvantages boys. The argument usually has two parts: one about who teaches, and one about how pupils are taught and assessed.
Who teaches
Teaching in England is mostly done by women, and primary teaching overwhelmingly so. In November 2024:
| State-funded schools, England | Teachers who were men |
|---|---|
| Nursery and primary | 13.8% |
| Secondary | 35.4% |
| All teachers | 24% (women: 76%) |
Supporters of the feminisation argument say this leaves boys without male role models in school, especially at primary level, where many children are taught by women throughout.
Tony Sewell and the feminisation debate
The argument is often linked to Tony Sewell. In a speech to the NASUWT teachers’ union in 2006, he argued that the drive for equality in schools had not taken enough account of the differences between boys and girls, and suggested recruiting more male teachers and using masculine role models, such as footballers, to promote reading. The speech was widely reported as an attack on the “feminisation” of schools. Sewell himself said he was not blaming female teachers, and argued that approaches that worked for boys would help girls too.
Does the gender of the teacher matter?
This is where the feminisation argument is weakest, because it has been tested directly. Bruce Carrington, Peter Tymms and Christine Merrell (2008) compared pupils taught by men and by women in British primary schools and found no effect of teacher gender on either pupils’ attainment or their attitudes to school. Boys did not do better with male teachers, and girls did not do better with female teachers.
Skelton, Francis and Valkanova (2007) add two further points. Women do outnumber men in primary teaching (by roughly five to one when they were writing), but primary school management had become more male, so it is misleading to describe primary schools as simply feminised. And they argue that the achievement gap is better explained by pupils’ ideas about gender, such as the belief that working hard is unmasculine, than by the sex of their teachers.
So the feminisation argument has to rest on the second part: how pupils are taught and assessed.
Assessment and coursework
GCSEs, first examined in 1988, included far more coursework than the O-levels they replaced, and girls overtook boys at 16 within a few years. It is often argued that coursework suited girls, who were seen as more organised and more willing to sustain effort over a long piece of work.
The timing is striking, but the evidence is weak. Skelton, Francis and Valkanova (2007) cite research by Arnot and colleagues (1999) which found that reducing coursework did little to change the pattern of gender achievement. Since then most coursework has been removed from GCSEs and A-levels, and girls are still ahead. If coursework had caused the gap, removing it should have closed it.
The timing argument, and why most sociologists now see the late-1980s reversal as part of wider social change, is covered on my post on explaining the gender gap in education.
Gender inequality in school: how girls are disadvantaged too
Girls get better results, but that doesn’t mean school treats them better. Feminist sociologists argue that achievement statistics hide several ways in which school still disadvantages girls.
Teacher attention
Research from the 1980s found that boys took up more of teachers’ time. Dale Spender, in Invisible Women: The Schooling Scandal (1982), recorded her own lessons after trying to divide her attention equally, and found she had spent 58% of the time talking to boys and 38% talking to girls. Michelle Stanworth (1981) found that pupils of both sexes said boys got the most attention in class. These studies are old, but they show how easily a teacher can treat pupils unequally without meaning to.
Subject choice and careers advice
Girls outperform boys overall, but they are still much less likely to take the subjects that lead to the best-paid careers, such as physics, computing and engineering. In a 2016 survey for Accenture, 57% of the teachers questioned admitted making subconscious stereotypes about girls and boys in relation to STEM subjects. The patterns, and the explanations, are on my post on gender and subject choice.
Sexual harassment
The strongest recent evidence comes from Ofsted’s 2021 Review of sexual abuse in schools and colleges, which visited 32 schools and colleges and spoke to more than 900 children and young people. 92% of girls, and 74% of boys, said sexist name-calling happened a lot or sometimes to them or their peers. Ofsted concluded that sexual harassment had become so normal that many pupils saw no point in reporting it. The full findings are on my post on gender socialisation in schools, and the feminist argument they support is on my post on the feminist perspective on education.
Girls’ identities
Louise Archer’s research on working-class girls found that the identities that brought them status among their peers, such as a glamorous, hyper-heterosexual feminine image, brought them into conflict with school. This is covered on my post on gender identity and education.
Evaluating in-school explanations
| Explanation | Strengths | Limitations |
|---|---|---|
| Teacher labelling | Fits the much higher exclusion rate for boys; teachers’ judgements of boys’ ability are coloured by behaviour | Doesn’t explain the timing: teachers held these stereotypes before girls overtook boys |
| Laddish subcultures | Jackson’s fear-of-failure explanation is well evidenced and explains why pupils avoid visible effort | Jackson found girls behaving laddishly too, so laddishness alone can’t explain a gap between boys and girls |
| Feminisation of teaching | Primary teaching is overwhelmingly female | Carrington, Tymms and Merrell (2008) found no effect of teacher gender on attainment or attitudes |
| Coursework | The timing fits the late-1980s reversal | Coursework has largely gone and girls are still ahead |
Three wider points are worth making in an essay.
In-school factors interact with factors outside school. Boys learn what counts as masculine at home and in their peer groups before school reinforces it. Skelton, Francis and Valkanova’s argument that the gap comes from pupils’ ideas about gender links the two: those ideas are learned outside school but acted out inside it.
Don’t overstate boys’ underachievement. The GCSE gap has more than halved since 2018/19 on the English and maths measure, and at A-level boys took a slightly larger share of the top grades in both 2025 and 2026. The debate about whether the concern over “failing boys” has been exaggerated is on my post on boys’ underachievement.
Gender is the smallest of the three achievement gaps. The disadvantage gap at GCSE is nearly nine times the gender gap. Any explanation of gender differences that ignores class and ethnicity is missing most of the picture.
How this comes up in the exam
In-school factors and gender have come up on Paper 1 (7192/1) more than any other part of the gender topic, because AQA often combines them with relationships and processes within schools in the 10-mark question:
- June 2025, Q03: Applying material from Item A, analyse two ways in which relationships and processes within schools may lead to gender differences in educational achievement. [10 marks] ([LINK NEEDED: June 2025 Q03 post])
- June 2024, Q03: Applying material from Item A, analyse two problems girls may experience as a result of relationships and processes in schools. [10 marks] ([LINK NEEDED: June 2024 Q03 post])
- June 2020 (sat November 2020), Q04: Applying material from Item B and your knowledge, evaluate sociological explanations of gender differences in educational achievement. [30 marks] See my answer to this essay.
In a 30-mark essay, use in-school factors as one side of the argument and factors outside school as the other, then evaluate both with the class and ethnicity comparison. For an essay that compares in-school factors across class, gender and ethnicity, see my answer to the in-school factors essay.
Sociology of Education Revision Bundle
Revise Education properly
Notes at two depths, so you can start early and finish fast — mid-depth notes to learn and consolidate from, and one-page summary sheets for the last fortnight.
Written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.
Signposting and Related Posts
This post has been written primarily for students studying the education topic, as part of the AQA’s A-Level Sociology course.
In-school factors are usually studied alongside the factors outside school: see explaining the gender gap in education.
For how pupils construct and perform gender in school, see gender identity and education; for how schools transmit gender norms as institutions, see gender socialisation in schools.
The same in-school processes applied to social class and ethnicity are covered on my posts on class and in-school factors and ethnicity and in-school factors.
More on this topic on my main sociology of education page.
Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com
Sources
- Department for Education, Key stage 4 performance, 2025/26 (published 15 October 2026)
- Department for Education, Suspensions and permanent exclusions in England, 2024/25 (published 9 July 2026)
- Department for Education, School workforce in England, November 2024 (teacher characteristics by sex)
- Ofsted, Review of sexual abuse in schools and colleges (10 June 2021)
- Carrington, B., Tymms, P. and Merrell, C. (2008) ‘Role models, school improvement and the “gender gap”: do men bring out the best in boys and women the best in girls?’, British Educational Research Journal, 34(3), 315–327
- Jackson, C. (2006) Lads and Ladettes in School: Gender and a Fear of Failure, Open University Press
- Skelton, C., Francis, B. and Valkanova, Y. (2007) Breaking Down the Stereotypes: Gender and Achievement in Schools, Equal Opportunities Commission, Working Paper 59
- Spender, D. (1982) Invisible Women: The Schooling Scandal
- Stanworth, M. (1981) Gender and Schooling
- Willis, P. (1977) Learning to Labour
- Accenture (2017) survey of 8,644 young people, parents and teachers in the UK and Ireland, carried out online in December 2016
- Tes, ‘Complex tales of males’ (7 July 2006), report of Tony Sewell’s speech to the NASUWT
Pingback: How I Would’ve Answered Yesterday’s AS Sociology Exam Paper (7191/1 – Education) | ReviseSociology
The problem of the male crisis has “not been looked at” in terms of much differential treatment that increases as we go down the socioeconomic ladder and more time in those environments. If we look in those areas, we cannot help but see how the numbers of Male problems diminish greatly as we go up the socioeconomic ladder. Even in higher socioeconomic areas, those Males are also falling behind their female peers. As we go down the socioeconomic ladder, the numbers increase greatly. We need to look at “much differential treatment of boys and girls beginning from infancy through adulthood. It is amazing to me that such differential treatment has not been looked at by the researchers. I imagine there are two reasons:
1. The belief in genetics has blinded researchers to the great social, environmental causes of learning, motivation, and academics. 2. The present view of average stress sees stress only as occurring in some present situation, event, or work. We need to see how our average stress is made up many layers of past, present, future – experiences, fears, preparations for defense, needs, values of others, and a host of unresolved mental work that remains with us we each carry as individuals as an average that takes up real mental energy from thinking, learning, motivation to learn, and affects our mental/emotional health.
To understand this we must redefine average stress as many layers of mental work that take up real mental energy. Picture an upright rectangle showing our full mental energy. Now begin at the bottom drawing in narrowly spaced, horizontal lines to represent many layers of past, present, future -experiences, *aggressions given children (that create long lasting mental conflict); values of self/others; anything creating unresolved mental work, needs, or anxiety both past and present. All of those layers are being mentally dealt with as layers of mental work. Stop about half way. The space leftover shows our leftover ability to think and learn. This shows just how environments and “differential treatment” greatly affect thinking and learning, not genetics. The Figure showing this will go to all on request.
The problem is more complex than school curriculum or boy chemistry. We need to stop looking at where boys are in life, character, and behavior and begin seeing how boys are treated from infancy very differently from us as girls. We need to see how the more aggressive treatment they are given from infancy by parents, teachers, and peers is creating more learning problems and less than correct behavior or care for authority and school.
To understand this, “we must redefine our average stress as many layers of mental work we carry with us that take away real mental energy leaving less mental energy to think, learn, concentrate, and enjoy the learning process”. This differential treatment creates very real differences in learning by individual and by group.
The problem involves two entirely different treatments of Males and Females as early as one year of age and increases in differential treatment. This is creating the growing Male Crisis. The belief Males should be strong allows more aggressive treatment of Males as early as one year, designed to create more layers of agitation, fear, and tension, so they will be prepared to fight, defend, and be tough. This is coupled with much “less” kind, stable, (very little verbal interaction) and less mental/emotional/social support, knowledge, and skills for fear of coddling. It is this more aggressive, less supportive treatment that creates the toughness or maintained, higher average layers of – anger, fear, anxiety, preparation for defense, etc. This remains in the mind as higher average stress that take away real mental energy needed for academics. This increases over time and continued by society from parents, yes teachers, and others in society. This creates more social/emotional distance/distrust of others -parents and other authority figures who have knowledge; lags in communication, lower social vocabulary, poor sentence structure; also higher average stress: more layers of mental agitated conflicts and fears taking away real mental energy that hurt learning and motivation to learn. This also creates more activity due to need for stress relief from their higher average stress. It creates more defensiveness and wariness of others further limiting social and emotional growth. The higher average stress creates higher muscle tension (creating more pressure on the pencil and tighter grip) that hurts writing and motivation to write (hurting the writing and creating early fatigue). It creates much lag in development due to lack of care, creating a learned sense of helplessness in school. This differential treatment continues through adulthood, almost fixing many Males onto roads of failure and escape into more short-term areas of enjoyment. Also society gives Males love and honor (essential needs for self-worth) only on condition of some achievement or status. This was designed to keep Male esteem and feelings of self-worth low to keep them striving and even give their lives in time of war for small measures of love and honor. Males not achieving in school or other are given more ridicule and discipline to make them try harder. Support is not an option for fear of coddling. Many Males thus falling behind in academics then turn their attention toward video games, and sports to receive small measures of love and honor not received in the classroom. The belief boys should be strong and the false belief in genetics creates a mental denial of any connection with differential treatment and the lower academics, lower esteem, and other problems, removing all good sense when it comes to raising boys today. I feel there is an almost emotional cannibalism allowed upon Males by society, even young Males who appear weak, all to make them tough.
Note, it is not just about feelings and more openness that is needed as it is more support and care in general from infancy. Remember it is the aggressive treatment that is increased for any sign of weakness and much wariness they feel for others, especially adults (parents and teachers) who feel it necessary – and more freely allowed to use more aggressive treatment for any sign of weakness or vulnerability.
As for reading, we need high social vocabulary, social experience with sentence structure, and “lower average stress to perform the abstract skill of reading: decoding, visualizing, organizing, reaching back into our social vocabulary to learn new words in print, and enjoying the process. Boys are deprived in these areas due to much less care, verbal interaction, and more aggressive treatment. This hurts boys in many ways when it comes to reading. As for writing, we also need much social vocabulary to understand and put words into print. We also need lower average stress to create more ease of writing. The substantial higher average stress in boys creates significant higher muscle tension, which then creates a much tighter grip and much more pressure on their pencil or pen. This creates poor handwriting and early fatigue. This later kills off motivation to write, hence more two and three word sentences from boys and very little writing. I feel the shows of masculinity and misbehavior are pretty much copouts to both show separation from failure in school and to gleam small measures of love and honor from peers. The defensiveness from authority is really pretty straight forward, especially in lower socioeconomic areas where strength, power, and status hold very real currency in those areas. For those students it is not just misbehavior but a real tug of war or fight for minimum feelings of self-worth from a continual fight they feel outside the classroom as well as in.
The suicide epidemic is the result of Males being deprived sufficiently from those essential feelings of self-worth of less love and honor simply for being boys or men. The training they are given from an early age is preventing many of them from competing in the information age and thus losing the means to secure legally – income, status, and power to earn in some way, love and honor from society. This is also creating many continual interactions with even more aggressive, less respectful treatment, which only increases their psychological suffering, which further wears down their feelings of self-worth or desire to live. This creates over time, psychological suffering that wears down their remaining feelings of self-worth to the point of suicide. There is no net provided for Male children and adults, all designed to make them tougher, even to the point of suicide. All persons given such treatment may escape in many ways given more harsh, less supportive treatment, and less respect over time. I feel we are seeing only Male suicides and not seeing all of the many harmful escapes many persons are using instead of suicide in the form of much drug and alcohol abuse, now mainly by Male children and adults.
As girls, we are treated much better and so enjoy more hope and care from society. Since we as girls by differential treatment are given much more positive, continual, mental, emotional/social support verbal interaction and care from an early age onward this creates quite the opposite outcome for girls compared with boys. We enjoy much more continuous care and support from infancy through adulthood and receive love and honor simply for being girls. This creates all of the good things: lower average stress for more ease of learning. We do enjoy much freedom of expression from much protection that makes us look less stable at times. Of course we can also use that same freedom of expression to give verbal, silent abuse, and hollow kindness/patronization to our Male peers with impunity knowing we are protected. We enjoy lower muscle tension for better handwriting/motivation; higher social vocabulary; lower average stress for reading/motivation; much more positive, trust/communication with adults, teachers, peers; and much more support for perceived weaknesses. We are reaping a bonanza in the information age. The lower the socioeconomic bracket and time in that bracket the more amplified the differential treatment from a young age and increased and more differentiated over time. Now with girls and women taking over many areas of society, we are enjoying even more lavishing of love and honor, while boys and men are still treated to be tough are failing more and so are being given even more ridicule and abuse by society and yes, also by girls and women using our protected freeness of expression and now, even from false feelings of superiority. My learning theory and article on the Male Crisis will go to all on request or can be read from my home site.
Pingback: Explaining the Gender Gap in Education | ReviseSociology