Academies in England: What They Are and Do They Work?

Last Updated on November 4, 2026 by Karl Thompson

An academy is a state-funded school that is independent of the local authority. Instead of being run by the council, it is run by an academy trust, a charitable company that gets its money directly from central government. Academies are free to attend and are inspected by Ofsted like any other state school.

Academies are an England-only policy. Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland don’t have them. By January 2026, 83.9% of state secondary schools in England and 48.8% of primary schools were academies, and academies taught 60.4% of all pupils in state-funded schools.

This post covers:

  1. what academies are, and the different types
  2. why schools become academies, including when they are made to
  3. the history of academies, from New Labour to the present Labour government
  4. academies today, in figures
  5. whether academies raise standards: the evidence
  6. what happens when academy trusts fail
  7. how to evaluate academies, with the sociological arguments.

Academies are part of the education policy topic in the sociology of education, examined on AQA Paper 1 (7192/1). They are a central example of marketisation.

What is an academy?

Academies have more control over their own affairs than local authority schools (often called ‘maintained’ or ‘community’ schools). They can:

  • manage their own budgets, with funding paid directly by central government rather than through the council
  • set their own term dates and length of the school day
  • employ their own staff, and (until the changes described below) set their own pay and conditions and employ teachers without qualified teacher status
  • choose not to follow the national curriculum.

They follow the same rules as other state schools on admissions, exclusions and special educational needs, and they are inspected by Ofsted.

The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 removes some of these freedoms. Academies will have to teach the new national curriculum (expected from September 2028), new teachers must have or be working towards qualified teacher status from 1 September 2027, and academy teachers come under the same core pay and conditions framework as other state school teachers.

Types of academy

Sponsored academies

Sponsored academies are usually schools that were underperforming and were taken out of local authority control and handed to a sponsor. In the early days sponsors were businesses, charities, universities, philanthropists and religious organisations. Today the sponsor is usually an established academy trust.

Converter academies

Converter academies are schools that chose to become academies. The Coalition opened this route to all schools from 2010, starting with schools rated outstanding, and converters quickly became the most common type.

Free schools

Free schools are brand-new academies, set up by groups such as parents, teachers, charities, trusts and faith groups. Legally, a free school is an academy. See my post on free schools: arguments and evidence for and against.

Single-academy and multi-academy trusts

Every academy belongs to a trust. A single-academy trust runs one school. A multi-academy trust (MAT) runs several, sometimes dozens, under one board and one chief executive. When a school joins a MAT it stops being a separate legal body: the trust, not the school, employs the staff and is responsible for the results.

Why do schools become academies?

Choosing to convert

A DfE survey of 720 academies in 2013 (published 2014) found that no single reason dominated. The reasons schools gave most often were raising educational standards, getting more money for front-line education, and having more freedom over how they used their funding. Money mattered most to the first wave of converters: 94% of schools that converted between May 2010 and April 2011 cited freedom to use funding as they saw fit, and 86% cited more funding for front-line education. Among those converting two years later, the figures were 78% and 60%, and more schools cited the chance to collaborate with others (60%, up from 37%).

The same survey asked what academies did with their freedoms. Three quarters had changed their curriculum (55%) or planned to (24%), and 84% linked pay to performance. Very few used their freedom over term dates: 4% had changed them and 5% planned to.

Being made to convert

Some schools had no choice. From 2016 the Education and Adoption Act put a duty on the Education Secretary to make an ‘academy order’ for any maintained school judged inadequate by Ofsted, so it would be taken over by a sponsor. This was often called forced academisation.

The Labour government changed that. The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 replaced the duty, from 29 June 2026, with a power the Education Secretary can choose whether to use. Most struggling schools now get support from RISE teams (Regional Improvement for Standards and Excellence) instead of an automatic change of management. More on RISE in my post on Labour education policy since 2024.

A history of academies

New Labour (1997–2010): city academies

Academies began under New Labour as ‘city academies’, and the first opened in 2002. They were aimed at failing schools in deprived urban areas, which were closed and reopened under a sponsor, often with new buildings. Andrew (now Lord) Adonis, then an education adviser to the Labour government, is usually credited with the policy.

The idea combined two things that run through New Labour policy. Academies extended the marketisation begun by the 1988 Education Reform Act, by adding diversity, choice and competition. But they were also targeted at disadvantaged areas, as a way of raising aspirations and breaking the cycle of deprivation. This mix of market and social justice is typical of New Labour’s ‘third way‘.

By 31 August 2010 there were 203 academies. The National Audit Office (2010) found that their GCSE results had been rising faster than those of similar maintained schools, though they were still below the national average.

Mossbourne Community Academy

The best-known early academy is Mossbourne Community Academy in Hackney, east London, which opened in September 2004 on the site of a failing school. Its first head, Sir Michael Wilshaw, ran a regime of high expectations, strict rules on behaviour, punctuality and uniform, extra lessons for pupils who needed them, and private-school-style activities such as debating and rowing. Wilshaw went on to become the chief inspector of Ofsted in January 2012.

Ofsted’s 2010 inspection judged Mossbourne outstanding (‘even within that category it is exceptional’). The proportion of pupils entitled to free school meals was very high, yet 86% gained five GCSEs at A* to C including English and maths. There is a question mark over how much of this was down to the new building, the extra money and the attention that came with being a flagship, and so over how far it can be a model for every school.

Mossbourne Academy students lining up before lessons

The Coalition (2010–2015): academies for all

The Coalition turned academies from a programme for failing schools into the normal model. The Academies Act 2010 let any school apply to convert, starting with outstanding schools from September 2010. The government also aimed to turn 200 underperforming primary schools into sponsored academies by 2012, and from 2012 academies could employ teachers without qualified teacher status.

The growth was rapid:

DateAcademies in England
31 August 2010203
31 July 2011803 (274 sponsored, 529 converters)
2 June 20121,907
January 201561.4% of state secondary schools and 14.6% of primary schools

Sources: NAO (2010); DfE, Academies Annual Report 2010/11; DfE, Schools, pupils and their characteristics, January 2015.

West and Bailey (2013) argue that the Coalition years were a ‘radical transformation’. Through ‘layering and policy revision’, together with austerity, private non-profit companies funded by central government rapidly replaced local authorities as the main providers of secondary education. More detail is in my post on Coalition education policy (2010–2015).

The Conservatives (2015–2024): the push for full academisation

The Education and Adoption Act 2016 introduced the duty to make academy orders for failing schools. The March 2016 white paper, Educational Excellence Everywhere, went further: all schools would be academies or converting by 2022. That met strong resistance, especially from good primary schools, and in May 2016 the government dropped the plan to force good and outstanding schools to convert.

The aim came back in a different form. The 2022 white paper, Opportunity for all, wanted every school to be in, or joining, a strong trust by 2030. The Schools Bill meant to carry this through was dropped in December 2022. See Conservative education policy 2015–2024.

Labour (2024 onwards): keeping trusts, reducing freedoms

Labour hasn’t abolished academies. The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 keeps them but brings them closer to other state schools: the national curriculum, qualified teachers and a common pay framework, plus new duties to cooperate with councils on admissions, and the end of the duty to issue academy orders. And the February 2026 white paper, Every child achieving and thriving, commits to ‘moving to all schools being part of school trusts’, including new trusts set up by local authorities, with no deadline.

The way academies are overseen has changed too. The Education and Skills Funding Agency, which funded academies, closed on 31 March 2025, and its work moved into the Department for Education; oversight of academy finances had already moved to the DfE’s Regions Group in October 2024.

Academies today

Type of school (England, January 2026)Share that are academies or free schools
Primary schools48.8%
Secondary schools83.9%
State-funded special schools53.1%
All state-funded schools48.2% of schools, teaching 60.4% of pupils

Source: DfE, Schools, pupils and their characteristics, academic year 2025/26 (published 4 June 2026).

So the typical secondary school is now an academy, but just under half of primary schools are. Academies teach a bigger share of pupils than their share of schools because secondary schools are larger.

Do academies raise standards?

This is the question the exam will push you on, and the honest answer is: it depends which academies, and when.

The early sponsored academies

The strongest evidence that academies can work comes from New Labour’s sponsored academies. Machin and Vernoit (2011) found that conversion was associated with a significant improvement in pupil performance, and that the effects were strongest in academies that had been open longest. Eyles and Machin (2019), studying the conversions of the 2000s, found that the effect on pupils’ results at the end of secondary school was ‘positive and significant’, and larger for urban academies and those that gained the most autonomy.

Note what this is evidence for: poorly performing schools given new leadership, new money and more autonomy in the 2000s. It doesn’t show that turning an already good school into an academy makes it better.

Academies in general

Stephen Gorard has been the most persistent sceptic. His 2009 study, ‘What are Academies the answer to?’ (Journal of Education Policy), questioned the early claims, and in a 2025 article he concluded that ‘academy schools are no better at raising attainment than the schools they replaced’. Once differences in intake are controlled for, he argues, the type of school a pupil attends in England isn’t linked to their results.

Anne West (2019) sums up the programme as having had ‘mixed results as regards pupils’ academic attainment’, while being costly for the public purse.

Trusts compared with local authorities

The Education Policy Institute (EPI, 2018) compared groups of schools and found ‘very little difference in the performance of academy trusts and local authorities’. What mattered more was how good the particular group was: pupils in the best-performing groups were about a term ahead at primary, and about half a grade per GCSE ahead at secondary, of those in the worst.

For disadvantaged pupils, the Sutton Trust’s Chain Effects 2018 report (Hutchings and Francis) found that in 38 of the 58 academy chains studied, disadvantaged pupils performed below the national average for all state schools in 2017. In 12 they performed above it. The same small groups of chains were at the top and the bottom year after year, and newer chains tended to do worse than long-established ones.

When trusts fail

Because a school in a multi-academy trust isn’t a separate legal body, its fate is tied to the trust’s. When a trust performs well that can help its schools. When it performs badly, a school can’t simply leave.

The best-known case is the Bright Tribe Trust. In September 2018 a BBC Panorama investigation alleged that it had claimed public money for building work it didn’t carry out as described. At Colchester Academy it was given £566,000 to demolish and rebuild unstable sports centre walls, but allegedly carried out a repair with metal braces that insiders said cost about £60,000. At Whitehaven Academy in Cumbria it allegedly claimed £320,000 for energy-efficient lighting but installed less than a third of the lights needed. The trust’s new leadership said the issues were ‘of serious concern’ and commissioned independent investigations. By then Bright Tribe was giving up its schools and was set to close. The EPI’s 2018 analysis had also ranked it the lowest-performing group of schools in the country.

What can happen to schools in a failing trust has also changed since then. Schools can be moved (‘rebrokered’) to another trust. The 2026 white paper proposes that a school could ask the regulator to let it leave its trust, which the Confederation of School Trusts opposes.

Evaluating academies

Diversity, choice and competition

Supporters, in the New Right tradition, argue that freeing schools from local authority control lets good leaders innovate, and that competition between schools drives up standards. The early sponsored academies, and schools like Mossbourne, are their best evidence.

The counter-evidence is that academy status on its own seems to make little difference. The EPI found the quality of the group mattered more than whether it was a trust or a council, and the Sutton Trust found most chains doing worse than average for disadvantaged pupils.

Accountability and local democracy

Local authorities are run by elected councillors who plan school places for their area. Academy trusts are run by appointed boards and are accountable to the Secretary of State through funding agreements. Walford (2014) argued that this replaced local democratic planning with a mix of providers, competition and unelected sponsors. Ward and Eden (2009) made a similar point about funding agreements being negotiated between the Secretary of State and the sponsor, outside local democratic oversight. The Bright Tribe case shows the risk: public money spent by bodies that local communities can’t hold to account.

Fragmentation

Critics argue that a system made up of hundreds of separate trusts, plus a shrinking number of council schools, is fragmented: no one plans places for a whole area, and councils have less money and fewer staff to support the schools still with them. Labour’s new duties on admissions and place planning, and the 2026 white paper’s plan for council-led trusts, can be read as an attempt to put some local planning back.

Privatisation and neoliberalism

Academies are a key example of what Ball and Youdell call endogenous privatisation (privatisation in education: running public schools like businesses, with chief executives, branding and performance pay) and of the wider neoliberal shift. West and Bailey’s (2013) title puts ‘privatising’ in inverted commas for a reason: trusts are non-profit, so this isn’t privatisation in the sense of private companies making profits from schools, but it does move control from elected councils to private charitable companies.

Can school structure fix inequality?

The deepest criticism is that changing who runs a school doesn’t change why some pupils do worse. Most of the main causes of class differences in achievement, such as material deprivation, lie outside the school. On this view, it was always unlikely that a change of structure would close the gap, and the evidence that chains vary as much as councils do fits that argument.

How academies come up in the exam

Academies are the main example for Paper 1 questions on marketisation, diversity and choice. For example:

  • AQA June 2022, Question 04: “Applying material from Item B and your knowledge, evaluate the view that marketisation policies have increased diversity and choice in the education system.” [30 marks]
  • AQA June 2023, Question 02: “Outline three criticisms of marketisation policies in education.” [6 marks]. Academies give you several: lack of local accountability, fragmentation, and little evidence that structure alone raises standards.
  • For a practice essay, see assess the view that education policies since 1988 have improved equality of educational opportunity.

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle

If you like this sort of thing, then you might like my sociology of education revision notes bundle, written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.

Signposting and Related Posts

This post has been written for students studying the education module as part of AQA A-level sociology. Related posts:

Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com

Sources
  • Department for Education (2011) Academies Annual Report 2010/11.
  • Department for Education (2014) Do academies make use of their autonomy? Research report DFE-RR366, July 2014.
  • Department for Education (2016) Educational Excellence Everywhere; (2022) Opportunity for all; (2026) Every child achieving and thriving, CP 1508-I.
  • Department for Education, Schools, pupils and their characteristics, January 2015 (SFR 16/2015) and academic year 2025/26.
  • Department for Education Education Hub (2026) ‘The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act: what parents need to know’, 12 May 2026.
  • Education and Adoption Act 2016; Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 (legislation.gov.uk).
  • Education Policy Institute (2018) School performance in multi-academy trusts and local authorities – 2018, as reported by Schools Week, 19 June 2018.
  • Eyles, A. and Machin, S. (2019) ‘The introduction of academy schools to England’s education’, Journal of the European Economic Association 17(4): 1107–1146.
  • Gorard, S. (2009) ‘What are Academies the answer to?’, Journal of Education Policy 24(1): 101–113; Gorard, S. (2025) ‘Academies haven’t raised pupil achievement’, Durham University / The Conversation, 14 January 2025.
  • Hutchings, M. and Francis, B. (2018) Chain Effects 2018, Sutton Trust.
  • Machin, S. and Vernoit, J. (2011) Changing school autonomy: academy schools and their introduction to England’s education, CEE Discussion Paper 123.
  • National Audit Office (2010) The Academies Programme, HC 288.
  • Ofsted (2010) inspection report, Mossbourne Community Academy, January 2010.
  • Schools Week (2018) ‘Bright Tribe investigated over false government funding claims’ (on the BBC Panorama investigation, September 2018).
  • West, A. and Bailey, E. (2013) ‘The development of the academies programme: “privatising” school-based education in England 1986–2013’, British Journal of Educational Studies 61(2): 137–159.
  • West, A. (2019) ‘The creation of academies in England: expected effects, evolution, observed effects and concerns’, Revue internationale d’éducation de Sèvres.
  • Written ministerial statement on the closure of the Education and Skills Funding Agency, 11 September 2024.

Leave a Reply

Turn on JavaScript to leave a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Exit mobile version
%%footer%%