Last Updated on November 3, 2026 by Karl Thompson
New Labour was in government from 1997 to 2010, under Tony Blair and then Gordon Brown. Its education policies had three main aims:
- Raising standards, largely by keeping and extending the Conservatives’ testing, inspection and league tables.
- Increasing diversity and choice, through specialist schools and academies.
- Improving equality of opportunity, through extra money for disadvantaged areas and pupils: Education Action Zones, Excellence in Cities, Sure Start and the Education Maintenance Allowance.
The verdict most sociologists reach is that standards rose but the gap between poorer pupils and the rest barely moved. The rest of this post explains each policy and then the evidence for and against.
Education policy is part of the sociology of education module, examined on AQA Paper 1 (7192/1). For a quick overview of every era of policy, see my education policies summary.

“Education, education, education”
In his speech to the Labour Party conference in October 1996, the year before the general election, Tony Blair said that his three main priorities for government would be “education, education, education”. It became the slogan most associated with New Labour’s approach to schools.
The phrase signalled that education would be central to the government’s plans, and the money followed. According to the Institute for Fiscal Studies, schools spending per pupil in England grew by about 5% a year in real terms during Labour’s time in office: from about £3,000 per pupil in 1997–98 to just under £5,700 in 2010–11 (in 2010 prices).
New Labour and the Third Way
New Labour wanted to appeal to middle-class voters who traditionally voted Conservative as well as to Labour’s traditional working-class supporters. The sociologist Anthony Giddens, in The Third Way (1998), described this as a ‘third way’ between the old left and the New Right.
You can see both influences in its education policies:
- From the New Right: New Labour kept the main features of marketisation introduced by the 1988 Education Reform Act (league tables, Ofsted inspections, parental choice), increased the diversity of school types, brought private sponsors into state education through academies, and emphasised preparing young people for work.
- From the social democratic perspective: it spent more on education overall and targeted extra money at disadvantaged areas and families, with the aim of improving equality of opportunity (or ‘social inclusion’, a favourite New Labour term).
Raising standards
Literacy, numeracy and class sizes
In primary schools, the National Literacy Strategy (the ‘literacy hour’) began in autumn 1998, and the National Numeracy Strategy (the daily maths lesson) in 1999. The School Standards and Framework Act 1998 also required infant classes to be limited to 30 pupils with one teacher, from the 2001–02 school year.
Targets, testing and inspection
New Labour largely welcomed the testing and inspection regime it inherited from the Conservatives, and extended it. Schools were set targets for test and exam results, and league tables carried more information, including ‘value added’ measures of the progress pupils made between entering and leaving a school. Ofsted continued to inspect schools, and schools judged to be failing could be closed and reopened under new management.
Critics argued that this created a culture of ‘teaching to the test’. Gillborn and Youdell’s research in two London secondary schools found teachers rationing their attention towards pupils on the borderline of a grade C, which they called the ‘A-to-C economy’: see Gillborn and Youdell: Rationing Education.
Specialist schools
Specialist schools were secondary schools that took on a specialism, such as science, technology, languages, sport or the arts, and received extra funding to develop it. The programme began under the Conservatives, and New Labour expanded it enormously. By September 2007 there were 2,799 specialist schools, about 80% of all maintained secondary schools in England.
Under the School Standards and Framework Act 1998, schools could select a small proportion of pupils by aptitude in certain specialist subjects. This links specialist schools to the wider debate about selection in education.
Specialist schools show New Labour moving away from the ‘one size fits all’ comprehensive school. They increased diversity and parental choice, in line with the New Right’s marketisation agenda. HOWEVER, critics argued that their better results partly reflected their intakes rather than the specialism itself, and that a programme covering four schools in five was hardly ‘specialist’ any more.
Academies
The academies programme (the first ones were called ‘city academies’) began in 2002. Academies were mostly failing schools in deprived urban areas that were closed and reopened outside local authority control, run by a sponsor such as a business, charity, university or faith group. By 31 August 2010 there were 203 open academies.
New Labour hoped academies would both raise standards and narrow the achievement gap. The evidence was mixed but broadly positive for the early academies:
- The National Audit Office (2010) found that the proportion of academy pupils getting five or more A*–C grades at GCSE was rising faster than in maintained schools with similar intakes, although it was still below the national average.
- Machin and Vernoit (2011) found that converting to an academy was associated with a significant improvement in pupil performance, though also with a ‘better’ pupil intake, and that the benefits took time to appear.
- HOWEVER, the NAO also found that the proportion of disadvantaged pupils in academies had fallen, although it remained over twice the national average, and that the attainment gap between more disadvantaged pupils and the rest had grown wider in academies than in comparable maintained schools.
The story of academies after 2010, when the Coalition turned them from a policy for failing schools into the norm, is covered in my post on academies.
Improving equality of opportunity
Education Action Zones
Education Action Zones (EAZs) were New Labour’s first big policy for tackling underachievement and social exclusion in deprived areas. Groups of schools, usually in poor urban areas, bid to become a zone and received extra funding. Each zone was run by an ‘action forum’ of representatives from the schools and their partners, which could include local businesses, parents and the local authority. The first 25 zones started in 1998–99 and a second round of 47 followed in September 2000, making 72 in all.
Ofsted’s 2003 evaluation was mixed:
- Attainment in English and maths at Key Stage 1 was rising in six of the seven zones inspected.
- Standards at Key Stage 2 were often static, and zones had not given enough priority to raising standards at Key Stage 3.
- At GCSE, the proportion of pupils getting five or more A*–C grades fell in two zones and was static in most others.
- Efforts to attract cash from business sponsors had limited success.
- Ofsted praised breakfast clubs, which it found popular and successful at getting the school day off to a good start, and homework clubs.
Excellence in Cities
Excellence in Cities (EiC) was launched in 1999, starting with secondary schools in big cities, and was later extended to primary schools. Its main strands were learning mentors, learning support units for pupils at risk of exclusion, and extra provision for gifted and talented pupils. Ofsted’s 2003 report found learning mentors to be the most successful and popular strand, and EiC to have a greater effect than EAZs on secondary school standards, particularly at Key Stage 3.
Sure Start
Sure Start Local Programmes, later Sure Start Children’s Centres, provided services for children under five and their families in disadvantaged areas: early education and childcare, parenting support and health services, all in one place. There were 3,631 designated children’s centres in England by April 2010.
The evidence on Sure Start has changed over time:
- The government’s own evaluation (the National Evaluation of Sure Start, at Birkbeck) found modest effects. Its 2008 study of over 9,000 three-year-olds in 150 Sure Start areas found less negative parenting and a better home learning environment, but no effect on vocabulary.
- Its follow-up of 7,258 five-year-olds found, among other effects, that children in Sure Start areas had lower BMIs (they were less likely to be overweight), but no difference on the Foundation Stage Profile measures of cognitive and social development.
- HOWEVER, the Institute for Fiscal Studies (2024) found much larger effects in the long run. Children living near a Sure Start centre scored 0.8 grades higher at GCSE than those living further away, and for children eligible for free school meals the effect was three grades.
How far Sure Start counts as compensatory education, and whether policies like it can make up for disadvantage at home, is covered in my post on compensatory education.
Every Child Matters
After the death of Victoria Climbié, the inquiry led by Lord Laming found that the agencies that had been in contact with her failed to share information and act together. The government’s response was the green paper Every Child Matters (September 2003), followed by the Children Act 2004. It aimed to put children at the centre of public services, with schools, social services and health working together around five outcomes for every child:
- being healthy
- staying safe
- enjoying and achieving
- making a positive contribution
- economic well-being
For schools, this meant teachers working more closely with other professionals, and a big expansion in support staff working with individual pupils.
The Education Maintenance Allowance
The Education Maintenance Allowance (EMA) paid students aged 16 to 19 from lower-income households to stay in education. It was piloted from 1999 and introduced across England from 2004–05. Payments depended on household income: in 2010–11, students from households earning under £20,817 got £30 a week, with £20 and £10 for higher income bands, up to £30,810. Students had to attend their lessons to be paid. The Coalition government ended EMA in England: no new applications were accepted from January 2011.
Raising the participation age
The Education and Skills Act 2008 required young people in England to stay in education or training beyond 16: until the end of the school year in which they turned 17 from 2013, and until their 18th birthday from 2015. This didn’t mean staying at school. Full-time education, an apprenticeship, or a job combined with part-time training all counted.
Curriculum and 14–19 reforms
New Labour also made several changes to what was taught:
- Citizenship became part of the National Curriculum in secondary schools.
- The curriculum became more flexible, with more vocational options at 14–19, including the new Diplomas.
- A-levels were split into AS and A2 halves, making them modular.
Vocational education as a whole, and the debate about whether it gives working-class students a real alternative or a second-class route, is covered in my post on sociological perspectives on vocational education.
Higher education: expansion and tuition fees
New Labour wanted more young people to go to university, and student numbers grew. But it also asked students to pay towards the cost:
- 1998: tuition fees were introduced for the first time. Most new full-time students were expected to contribute up to £1,000 a year, depending on their own and their parents’ income, so students from lower-income families still paid nothing. Maintenance grants were largely replaced by loans.
- 2004: the Higher Education Act 2004 allowed universities to charge ‘variable’ fees of up to £3,000 a year from 2006–07, if they had an access agreement with the new Office for Fair Access. Fees were paid back through loans once graduates earned over £15,000 a year. The cap had risen to £3,225 by 2009–10.
Did fees put working-class students off? Connor et al. (2001), in research for the government, found that cost was a factor in the decision not to go to university, but not the main one: working-class respondents were more likely to want to start work and be independent, and to be less confident that they would succeed. The Coalition later raised the cap to £9,000 from 2012: see my post on Coalition education policy.
Evaluating New Labour’s education policies
Standards rose
Exam results rose throughout New Labour’s time in office, more pupils stayed on after 16, and more went to university. Spending per pupil nearly doubled in real terms, much of it on buildings, staff and support for schools in poor areas. Supporters point to the early academies, EMA, and the long-run effects of Sure Start found by the IFS as evidence that targeted spending can work.
The gap barely moved
HOWEVER, the gap between the poorest pupils and the rest hardly changed. In 2006–07 the gap between pupils eligible for free school meals and all other pupils, in the proportion getting five or more A*–C grades including English and maths, was 27.9 percentage points. By 2009–10, Labour’s last year, it was 27.6. Results rose for everyone, but the gap between rich and poor stayed almost exactly where it was.
Markets favour the middle classes
Sociologists such as Stephen Ball argue that New Labour’s choice and diversity policies mainly benefited the middle classes. Middle-class parents have the cultural and material capital to work the system: to research schools, move into catchment areas and appeal against decisions. Gewirtz, Ball and Bowe (1995) called them ‘privileged/skilled choosers’. Working-class parents were more likely to send their children to the nearest school. See my post on unequal parental choice.
Expecting too much of schools
Paul Trowler (2003) argued that New Labour was unrealistic about what education alone could achieve: schools cannot overcome deep-rooted social inequalities on their own. New Labour’s heavy focus on school targets and performance implied that underachievement was mainly the schools’ fault, rather than the result of poverty and inequality outside the school gates. This links to the evidence on material deprivation and education.
A Third Way, or more of the same?
New Right critics argue that New Labour didn’t go far enough with markets and that spending more money doesn’t guarantee better results. Marxist and critical sociologists argue the opposite: that by keeping league tables, testing and choice, New Labour carried on the neoliberal project of the Conservatives, just with more money attached.
How New Labour’s policies come up in the exam
Education policy comes up on AQA Paper 1 in every format: as an outline question (4 or 6 marks), as an ‘applying material from Item A’ 10-marker, and as a 30-mark essay. New Labour’s policies are useful in any question about policy and equality of opportunity, marketisation, or diversity and choice. Because they combine market policies with equality policies, they are a good test case for the question of whether education policy can make up for inequality in society.
- For a practice 30-mark essay, see assess the view that education policies since 1988 have improved equality of educational opportunity.
- For a real AQA 10-mark question on parental choice, see analyse two effects of increased parental choice on pupils’ experience of education.
Sociology of Education Revision Bundle
Revise Education properly
Notes at two depths, so you can start early and finish fast — mid-depth notes to learn and consolidate from, and one-page summary sheets for the last fortnight.
Written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.
Signposting and Related Posts
This post has been written for students studying the education module as part of AQA A-level sociology. Education policy is usually taught in historical order:
- Before New Labour: the 1988 Education Reform Act, which introduced marketisation.
- After New Labour: Coalition education policy (2010–2015), which expanded academies and introduced free schools.
- For every era on one page: education policies: a summary.
Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com
Sources
- Chowdry, H., Muriel, A. and Sibieta, L. (2010) Education policy, IFS Briefing Note BN98, Institute for Fiscal Studies.
- Connor, H. et al. (2001) Social Class and Higher Education: Issues Affecting Decisions on Participation by Lower Social Class Groups, DfEE Research Report RR267.
- Department for Education and Skills (2003) Every Child Matters, Cm 5860.
- Department for Education (2012) GCSE and Equivalent Attainment by Pupil Characteristics in England, 2010/11, SFR 03/2012.
- Department for Education (2019) Number of children’s centres, 2003 to 2019.
- Gewirtz, S., Ball, S. and Bowe, R. (1995) Markets, Choice and Equity in Education, Open University Press.
- Giddens, A. (1998) The Third Way, Polity.
- Gillborn, D. and Youdell, D. (2000) Rationing Education, Open University Press.
- House of Commons Library (2011) Education Maintenance Allowance (EMA), SN/SG/5778.
- House of Commons Library (2016) Tuition Fee Statistics, Briefing Paper 917.
- Institute for Fiscal Studies (2024) The short- and medium-term impacts of Sure Start on educational outcomes.
- Machin, S. and Vernoit, J. (2011) Changing School Autonomy: Academy Schools and their Introduction to England’s Education, CEE Discussion Paper 123, LSE.
- National Audit Office (2010) The Academies Programme, HC 288.
- National Evaluation of Sure Start (2008) The Impact of Sure Start Local Programmes on Three Year Olds and Their Families; (2010) …on Five Year Olds and Their Families, DFE-RR067.
- Ofsted (2003) Excellence in Cities and Education Action Zones: management and impact, HMI 1399.
- Ofsted (2003) The national literacy and numeracy strategies and the primary curriculum, HMI 1973.
- Trowler, P. (2003) Education Policy, 2nd edn, Routledge.
Glad it helped!
Really helpful. Used this to discuss with my daughter for her gcse revision