Where Private Profit Meets Public Necessity: The Special Needs Education Crisis

Last Updated on November 8, 2026 by Karl Thompson

Demand for special educational needs (SEN) support in England has risen sharply, and a growing share of the places for children with the most complex needs is now provided by private companies, paid for by local councils. This makes special needs education one of the clearest current examples of the privatisation of education: public money paying private providers to deliver a state service.

This post sets out what has happened, looks at one widely reported case, and explains how sociologists would analyse it. It’s a contemporary case study you can use in answers on privatisation and neoliberalism in education, for AQA A-level Sociology Paper 1 (7192/1).

diagram showing the privatisation of SEN. Abstract money going from the UK to the middle east.

What has happened

Councils have a legal duty to secure a suitable school place for every child with an Education, Health and Care Plan (EHCP), the document setting out the support a child with special needs is entitled to. The number of children with EHCPs has almost doubled: from about 237,000 in 2016 to about 434,000 in 2024.

Many of these children need a place in a special school. Where councils don’t have enough places in state special schools, they pay for places in independent (private) special schools instead. According to the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS):

MeasureFigure
Pupils in independent special schoolsabout 13,000 in 2015; nearly 30,000 in 2024
Average cost per place, independent special school£61,500 a year
Average cost per place, state special school£23,900 a year
Councils’ planned spending on independent special school fees, 2024–25£1.8 billion

Source: Sibieta and Snape (2024), IFS.

So the number of pupils in independent special schools has more than doubled in under a decade, and each place costs the taxpayer, on average, around two and a half times as much as a place in a state special school.

A case study: Pontville School

One case has been widely reported. Writing in the i newspaper in June 2025, the journalist Ian Birrell reported that Pontville, a private special school in Lancashire, charged councils up to £116,611 per pupil a year, which he described as almost double the fees at Eton. He reported that an Ofsted inspection had found that a “significant minority” of pupils felt unsafe and that some pupils were “held by staff in restrictive physical interventions multi-times per day”.

Birrell also reported that Pontville is run by Witherslack, one of the biggest companies in the sector, which he said is owned by Mubadala, an Abu Dhabi sovereign wealth fund. His argument was that money British councils spend on children with special needs is ending up with overseas investors.

Bear in mind that Birrell’s article is an opinion column, and that a school’s Ofsted judgement can change after a new inspection. If you use this example, attribute it to Birrell’s reporting, and check Ofsted’s website for the school’s latest report.

Why this is privatisation

Stephen Ball and Deborah Youdell distinguish two kinds of privatisation in education. Endogenous privatisation is privatisation in public education: business methods brought inside state schools. Exogenous privatisation is privatisation of public education: in their words, “the opening up of public education services to private sector participation on a for-profit basis”.

Special needs provision is a clear case of exogenous privatisation. The child is entitled to the place by law, and the council pays for it with public money, but a private company provides it and can make a profit from it. See my post on neoliberalism and the privatisation of education.

The arguments

Arguments for private provision

  • Capacity. When demand rose faster than councils could build special schools, private providers supplied places that children needed and were legally entitled to. Without them, many children would have had no suitable place at all.
  • Specialist expertise. Some independent special schools offer highly specialised support, for example for particular types of autism or complex needs, that a council could not provide for a small number of children.
  • Choice. From a New Right or neoliberal point of view, a mix of providers gives parents more options, and competition should push providers to improve.

Arguments against

  • Cost. Places cost the taxpayer around two and a half times as much as state special school places, at a time when many councils are struggling with deficits in their high-needs budgets.
  • Profit and debt. Critics argue that some of the money ends up as profit, interest on debt or returns to investors, rather than being spent on children. The same concern has been raised about private equity in nurseries: research led by Antonia Simon at UCL (2022) found heavily indebted for-profit nursery groups with low or negative reserves.
  • Quality and accountability. Councils have little bargaining power when there are no state places available, so they may have to accept a provider’s fees. Critics argue that this weakens accountability for quality, as the Pontville reporting suggests.
  • A Marxist reading would see this as public money for a vulnerable group being turned into a source of private profit.
  • A social democratic reading would argue that the solution is more state provision: building enough special school places so that councils aren’t dependent on the private sector.

What the government is doing

In February 2026 the government announced plans for new statutory standards for independent special schools, national price bands and full transparency about costs. The schools white paper, Every child achieving and thriving (February 2026), launched a consultation on reforming the SEND system. Whether these changes reduce costs, and how private providers respond, is a live question, and a useful one for evaluation.

Using this in the exam

This case study works as up-to-date evidence in answers on:

  • privatisation (as an example of exogenous privatisation)
  • neoliberal and New Right perspectives on education (as evidence for and against market provision)
  • the role of the state in education

Keep it brief in an essay: one or two sentences, with the key figure (independent special school places costing about two and a half times as much as state ones) and what it shows.

Related posts

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle

If you like this sort of thing, then you might like my sociology of education revision notes bundle, written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.

Signposting

This post is part of the sociology of education module.

Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com

Sources
  • Association of Educational Psychologists (2026) ‘Government announces end to runaway special school fees’, 20 February.
  • Ball, S. and Youdell, D. (2007) Hidden Privatisation in Public Education, Education International.
  • Birrell, I. (2025) column in the i, 2 June.
  • Department for Education (2026) Every child achieving and thriving (schools white paper), February.
  • Institute for Fiscal Studies (2025), education spending analysis (EHCP numbers).
  • Sibieta, L. and Snape, D. (2024) Spending on special educational needs in England: something has to change, IFS Report R341.
  • Simon, A. et al. (2022) Acquisitions, Mergers and Debt: the new language of childcare, UCL Social Research Institute.

Leave a Reply

Turn on JavaScript to leave a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Exit mobile version
%%footer%%