Marketisation of Education

Last Updated on November 6, 2026 by Karl Thompson

Marketisation is one of the most important concepts in the sociology of education. It means bringing market forces into education, so that schools compete with each other for pupils in the same way businesses compete for customers. Since the 1988 Education Reform Act, every government has kept the basic market framework: parental choice, funding that follows the pupil, published results and inspection.

This post explains what marketisation means, where the idea comes from, the policies that created the education market, how marketisation makes schools run like businesses, and what sociologists say about its effects. It finishes with a real AQA exam question and a list of every marketisation question set on Paper 1 so far. Marketisation is part of the education module, examined on AQA Paper 1 (7192/1).

Key terms

TermMeaning
MarketisationBringing market forces of competition and consumer choice into education, so that schools compete for pupils and the funding that comes with them
Quasi-marketA market inside a public service. Education is still paid for by the state and free to pupils, but schools compete for pupils and parents choose between them. The economist Julian Le Grand developed the concept for the reforms of the late 1980s and early 1990s
Parentocracy‘Rule by parents’: a system where parents’ choices, rather than pupils’ ability and effort, shape education. Phillip Brown’s (1990) term, which he used critically
DiversityA wider range of types of school (academies, free schools, faith schools, grammar schools and so on) for parents to choose between
ChoiceParents’ freedom to choose their child’s school, rather than being allocated the nearest one

Where the idea of marketisation comes from

Marketisation comes from the New Right and from neoliberal economics. Both argue that state-run services are inefficient because they face no competition. A school that is guaranteed its pupils has no reason to improve.

The solution is a market. If parents can choose schools, and schools’ funding depends on how many pupils they attract, then good schools will grow and poor schools will have to improve or close. Competition, on this view, drives up standards for everyone.

The best-known statement of the argument is by two American political scientists, John Chubb and Terry Moe. In Politics, Markets and America’s Schools (1990), they argued that state schools performed poorly because they were run by democratic, bureaucratic control rather than by parent choice and competition. Their answer was an education market built on parental choice.

Marketisation policies in England

The education market wasn’t created by one policy. It was built up over almost forty years by governments of both main parties.

YearPolicyWhat it added to the market
1980Education Act 1980Parents could express a preference for a school
1988Education Reform Act: open enrolmentPopular schools had to take pupils up to their capacity, so parents’ choices had real effects
1988Education Reform Act: local management of schools and formula fundingMost of a school’s budget followed its pupils, so every pupil gained or lost meant money gained or lost
1988Education Reform Act: grant-maintained schools and city technology collegesNew types of state school outside local authority control: the start of diversity
1988Education Reform Act: national curriculum and testingCommon tests made schools’ results comparable
1992League tablesSecondary schools’ results published every year, giving parents ‘market information’
1992Ofsted (Education (Schools) Act 1992)Inspection reports, from 1993, as another source of information for parents
1997–2010New Labour: specialist schools and academies2,799 specialist schools by 2007, about 80% of maintained secondaries; the first academies from 2002
2010Academies Act 2010 (Coalition)Every school could apply to become an academy
2011Free schoolsNew state-funded schools set up by parents, teachers, charities and faith groups. The first 24 opened in 2011; 425 were open by 2016
2016Education and Adoption Act 2016A duty to turn schools judged to be failing into academies

By January 2026, 83.9% of state secondary schools in England and 48.8% of primary schools were academies, teaching 60.4% of all pupils.

The direction has recently shifted a little. The Labour government’s Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 requires academies to follow the national curriculum from 2028 and to employ qualified teachers from September 2027, and restores councils’ power to open new schools. The 2016 duty to turn failing schools into academies was removed in June 2026. The market framework of choice and per-pupil funding remains, but some of the differences between academies and other schools are being reduced.

For the policies in detail, see my posts on the 1988 Education Reform Act, league tables, academies, free schools and education policies: a summary.

How marketisation makes schools run like businesses

Marketisation changes how schools behave, not just how they’re funded. Sociologists point to four ways schools have come to be run more like businesses.

1. Competing for customers

Under open enrolment and formula funding, pupils bring money with them. A school that loses pupils loses income, so schools have to compete for ‘customers’. League table positions and Ofsted grades become the main way schools compete, and schools put time and money into improving them.

2. Offering a distinctive ‘product’

Businesses also compete by offering something rivals don’t. Schools do the same: a specialism, a faith ethos, a strict behaviour policy, a ‘grammar school’ stream or a particular academy brand. This is the diversity side of marketisation: different types of school for parents to choose between.

3. Marketing and image

In a market, schools need to attract parents, so they put more effort into marketing: open evenings, prospectuses, websites, social media and how the school looks to visitors. Critics argue that this diverts money and attention from teaching.

4. Business-style management

Headteachers increasingly act as managers, and large academy trusts are run by chief executives. Sharon Gewirtz, in The Managerial School (2002), argued that marketisation and managerialism changed what schools are like. Families are treated as consumers, schools compete for enrolment in local markets, and business methods such as setting targets and monitoring performance govern how schools are run. Her research with teachers looked at what this did to school culture and to social justice.

Marketisation and privatisation: what’s the difference?

Students often confuse these. Ball and Youdell distinguish two kinds of privatisation in education:

  • Endogenous privatisation is privatisation in public education: business ideas and methods brought inside state schools, such as competition, league tables and performance management. Marketisation is endogenous privatisation.
  • Exogenous privatisation is privatisation of public education: private companies taking over parts of the system, such as running services, selling exam and testing services or providing technology.

So marketisation makes schools behave like businesses, while exogenous privatisation lets actual businesses into education. See neoliberalism and the privatisation of education.

Has marketisation worked? The arguments for

  • Standards rose. Exam results rose steadily after 1988, which the New Right take as evidence that competition works. (Grade inflation is the obvious counter-argument: see the New Right’s view of education.)
  • More diversity. Parents now choose between many more types of school than before 1988.
  • More information. League tables and Ofsted reports mean parents can compare schools, which they couldn’t do before.
  • Every government has kept it. No government since 1988, Conservative or Labour, has dismantled the market framework.

The arguments against

Choice is unequal

Gewirtz, Ball and Bowe (1995) found that middle-class parents were ‘privileged/skilled choosers’. They had the cultural capital to research schools, understand admissions rules and appeal, and the economic capital to move near a popular school or pay for transport. Many working-class parents were ‘disconnected choosers’, who chose the nearest school. See unequal parental choice.

Phillip Brown (1990) argued that education was moving from a meritocracy towards a ‘parentocracy’, in which success depends on “the wealth and wishes of parents rather than the abilities and efforts of pupils”. Critics call the New Right’s claim that all parents have real choice the myth of parentocracy.

Schools choose parents, not the other way round

Popular, oversubscribed schools can ‘cream-skim’ the pupils most likely to boost their results, and avoid pupils who might pull results down (‘silt-shifting’). Because funding follows pupils, a school that does well gains money as well as results. The least popular schools lose both. Critics call this polarisation. See the 1988 Education Reform Act.

League tables distort teaching and mislead parents

Gillborn and Youdell found teachers concentrating on pupils at the borderline of a grade C, because those pupils could raise the school’s league table position: what they called educational triage and the ‘A-to-C economy’. See Gillborn and Youdell: Rationing Education.

The statisticians Leckie and Goldstein found that differences in schools’ results mostly reflect differences in their intakes, and that very few schools can be reliably told apart once uncertainty is allowed for. They concluded that league tables have little to offer parents choosing a school.

The market is tightly controlled by the state

Schools are told to compete, but the state decides what they teach, how pupils are tested and how schools are inspected. Some sociologists describe this as fragmented centralisation: the school system is broken up into many different types of school (fragmented), while real power moves to central government (centralisation).

The perspectives

  • New Right and neoliberals: marketisation raises standards, gives parents power and makes schools responsive.
  • Social democrats: markets reproduce inequality unless balanced by state spending targeted at disadvantaged pupils.
  • Marxists: marketisation lets the middle class use its economic and cultural capital to reproduce its advantage, while the language of ‘choice’ makes the results look fair.
  • Postmodernists: a diverse system fits a diverse society, but a national curriculum and national tests limit how different schools can really be. See postmodernism and education.

Exam question: AQA June 2020 (sat November 2020), Question 03

This is a real AQA question. The June 2020 paper was sat in November 2020.

03 Read Item A below and answer the question that follows.

Item A
Businesses compete with each other to attract customers. Another route to success for businesses is to provide unique products for their customers. The introduction of marketisation policies into the state education system means that schools are run like businesses.

Applying material from Item A, analyse two ways in which marketisation policies have led to schools being run like businesses. [10 marks]

The mark scheme

The top band, 8–10, asks for good knowledge of two ways schools are run more like businesses, two developed applications of the item, and appropriate analysis or evaluation. Sources listed include Ball, Bartlett and Le Grand, Chubb and Moe, David, Gewirtz, Hall, Molnar and Whitty.

How to approach it

Item A gives you two hooks: businesses compete for customers, and they succeed by offering something different. Use one for each of your two ways. That gets the application marks, because you are clearly building on the item rather than writing a general answer. Then develop each way with a policy, a sociologist and an evaluation point.

Stay on the question. It’s about schools being run like businesses, not about educational achievement. AQA’s mark scheme warns that answers drifting into achievement stay in the bottom band.

Model answer

Way 1: schools compete for customers. Item A says that businesses compete with each other to attract customers. Marketisation policies have made schools do the same. Open enrolment, introduced by the 1988 Education Reform Act, meant popular schools had to take pupils up to their capacity, and formula funding meant most of a school’s budget followed its pupils. So every pupil a school attracts brings in money, and every pupil it loses costs it money, just as customers do for a business.

Schools compete mainly through their league table positions and Ofsted grades, because these are what parents use to compare them. This changes how schools are run. Gewirtz (2002) argued that schools increasingly adopted business methods such as targets and performance monitoring, and treated parents as consumers. Gillborn and Youdell found schools concentrating teaching on pupils at the C/D borderline, because they could lift the school’s results (‘educational triage’). HOWEVER, competition may not be fair: Leckie and Goldstein found that differences in schools’ results mostly reflect their intakes, so schools with middle-class intakes win the competition regardless of how well they are run.

Way 2: schools offer a distinctive product. Item A says businesses can also succeed by offering goods that others don’t. Marketisation encourages schools to differentiate themselves in the same way, so that they appeal to particular groups of parents. New Labour’s specialist schools programme meant that by 2007 about 80% of maintained secondary schools had a specialism, and academies and free schools were given freedoms over the curriculum and ethos so they could offer something different from local authority schools. Faith schools offer a religious ethos, and some schools market a strict behaviour policy or a ‘grammar stream’. Schools then advertise these differences through prospectuses, open evenings and websites, as businesses advertise their products.

HOWEVER, the differences may be more about branding than reality. A DfE study of 720 academies (2014) found that only 4% had changed their term dates, though 55% had made some change to their curriculum. From 2028 academies must follow the national curriculum again. So schools are run like businesses in how they present themselves, but the ‘products’ they offer may be more similar than their marketing suggests.

Every marketisation question on Paper 1 so far

Marketisation has come up five times on Paper 1 since the current specification started. Here they are, with where to find an answer.

SeriesQuestionWhere to find an answer
June 2018, Q01 (4 marks)Outline two reasons why marketisation policies may produce inequality of educational achievement between social classes.Marketisation and inequality of opportunity
June 2020 (sat November 2020), Q03 (10 marks)Applying material from Item A, analyse two ways in which marketisation policies have led to schools being run like businesses.This post (above)
June 2022, Q04 (30 marks)Applying material from Item B and your knowledge, evaluate the view that marketisation policies have increased diversity and choice in the education system.[LINK NEEDED: June 2022 Q04 essay]
June 2023, Q02 (6 marks)Outline three criticisms of marketisation policies in education.The 1988 Education Reform Act
June 2024, Q02 (6 marks)Outline three reasons why parental choice may be limited when selecting a school for their child.Unequal parental choice

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle

If you like this sort of thing, then you might like my sociology of education revision notes bundle, written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.

Signposting and Related Posts

This post is part of the education module for AQA A-level sociology. Related posts:

Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com

Sources
  • AQA (2020) A-level Sociology 7192/1, June 2020 (November 2020 series): question paper and mark scheme.
  • Brown, P. (1990) ‘The “Third Wave”: education and the ideology of parentocracy’, British Journal of Sociology of Education, 11(1), pp. 65–86.
  • Chubb, J. E. and Moe, T. M. (1990) Politics, Markets and America’s Schools, Brookings Institution Press.
  • Department for Education (2014) Do academies make use of their autonomy?, Research Report RR366.
  • Department for Education (2026) Schools, pupils and their characteristics: 2025/26.
  • Education Reform Act 1988 (legislation.gov.uk).
  • Gewirtz, S. (2002) The Managerial School: Post-welfarism and Social Justice in Education, Routledge.
  • Gewirtz, S., Ball, S. and Bowe, R. (1995) Markets, Choice and Equity in Education, Open University Press.
  • Gillborn, D. and Youdell, D. (2000) Rationing Education, Open University Press.
  • Le Grand, J. (1991) ‘Quasi-markets and social policy’, The Economic Journal, 101(408), pp. 1256–1267.
  • Leckie, G. and Goldstein, H. The Limitations of Using School League Tables to Inform School Choice, University of Bristol.
  • PricewaterhouseCoopers for DCSF (2008) Evaluation of the Specialist Schools Programme, DCSF-RW034.

Leave a Reply

Turn on JavaScript to leave a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Exit mobile version
%%footer%%