Class Differences in Education: The Role of In-School Factors

Last Updated on November 1, 2026 by Karl Thompson

In-school factors are the processes inside schools that help explain why working-class pupils, on average, do worse than middle-class pupils. Cultural and material deprivation look at the home. This side of the debate looks at what happens once children walk through the school gate. The key points are:

  1. Howard Becker (1952) found that teachers judged pupils against an “ideal pupil” who was, in practice, middle class.
  2. Teacher labelling can become a self-fulfilling prophecy, and labels are often shaped by class.
  3. Banding, setting and streaming tend to put working-class pupils in lower groups, where expectations are lower.
  4. Some working-class pupils respond by forming anti-school subcultures, though Mac an Ghaill showed the picture is more varied than Willis suggested.
  5. The hidden curriculum and educational triage can disadvantage working-class pupils without anybody intending it.

This is part of the topic of social class differences in educational achievement within the sociology of education, examined on AQA Paper 1 (7192/1). The specification calls this area “relationships and processes within schools”. Most of the studies below have their own detailed posts, linked as you go; this post pulls together the class side of them.

a mind map summarising the in school factors which explain social class inequalities in educational achievement, including teacher labelling and pupil subcultures.

Becker’s ideal pupil (1952)

Howard Becker was an American interactionist sociologist. In the early 1950s he interviewed 60 teachers working in Chicago schools about the pupils they taught, and published the findings in 1952 as “Social-class variations in the teacher-pupil relationship”.

Becker found that the teachers carried around an image of the ideal pupil, and judged real pupils by how closely they matched it. The teachers judged children on their appearance, conduct, manners and morals as well as their ability, and the pupils who came closest to the ideal were middle class. Children from lower-class backgrounds were seen as further from the ideal: harder to teach, harder to control and less acceptable in their behaviour. Teachers found teaching them less rewarding.

The important point is that none of these judgements was about intelligence alone. Two pupils of similar ability could be seen very differently because of the way they dressed, spoke and behaved, and those differences ran along class lines.

HOWEVER, Becker’s study tells us what teachers thought, not what happened to the pupils as a result. It’s an interview study of teachers in one American city in the early 1950s, so you need to be careful about generalising it to schools in Britain today.

A small correction worth knowing: many textbooks say Becker’s ideal pupil spoke in the elaborated speech code. That’s a later link with Bernstein made by textbook writers, not something Becker’s teachers said. It’s a fair analysis point if you present it as yours.

Teacher labelling and the self-fulfilling prophecy

Becker’s work fed into labelling theory: the idea that teachers attach labels to pupils (bright, thick, troublemaker), and that pupils may come to see themselves in those terms and act accordingly. When a label comes true because it was applied, that’s a self-fulfilling prophecy.

The study with the clearest class angle is Ray Rist’s (1970) study of an American kindergarten. Within the first eight days of school, the teacher had seated the children at three tables. Rist found the seating reflected the children’s social class background rather than any measured ability, and the groupings carried on into the first and second grade.

Rosenthal and Jacobson (1968) are the classic experimental study of the self-fulfilling prophecy. Later reviews of the research found that teacher expectation effects are real but usually small, and that they tend to be larger for low achievers, for pupils from lower socio-economic backgrounds and for African American pupils (Jussim and Harber, 2005). That’s a useful finding for a class essay: labelling may matter most for exactly the pupils this topic is about.

Nell Keddie (1971) looked at classroom knowledge in a London comprehensive. She found teachers treated pupils in higher streams as able to handle abstract, academic knowledge, while the everyday knowledge lower-stream pupils brought to lessons was treated as less valid. Pupils in different streams were in effect given access to different kinds of knowledge.

The full treatment of labelling, including Hargreaves, Hester and Mellor and the criticisms of Rosenthal and Jacobson, is in my post on labelling theory and the self-fulfilling prophecy.

Banding, setting and streaming

Grouping pupils by ability is one of the main ways labels become built into the organisation of a school.

Stephen Ball’s study of “Beachside Comprehensive” (1981) followed pupils who were placed into three bands when they arrived, using information from their primary schools. Ball found that pupils of similar ability were more likely to end up in the top band if their fathers had non-manual (middle-class) jobs. Pupils arrived eager and conformist, but over time those in the lower bands, particularly band two, became more anti-school.

The same pattern carries into GCSE tiers. A pupil entered for the foundation tier can achieve at most a grade 5, so decisions about sets, often made years earlier, put a ceiling on what some pupils can achieve.

For the details, including current research on grouping, see my post on setting and streaming.

Educational triage

David Gillborn and Deborah Youdell (2000) argued that league tables built around the proportion of pupils getting five A*–C grades created an A-to-C economy in schools. Schools responded with educational triage: sorting pupils into those who would pass anyway, borderline pupils who could be pushed over the line with extra help, and those seen as hopeless cases. Resources went to the borderline group. The pupils written off were disproportionately Black and working class.

Headline measures have changed since then (Progress 8 replaced the five A*–C measure in 2016), but triage is still a useful concept whenever schools are judged on a single threshold. The full study is in my post on Gillborn and Youdell: Rationing Education.

Pupil subcultures

Labelling and setting can push pupils into groups that reject the values of the school. This is where pupil subcultures come in.

Paul Willis (1977) studied twelve working-class boys, “the lads”, through their last eighteen months at school and into their first months at work. The lads formed a counter-school culture. They saw academic work as pointless, valued “having a laff”, and looked down on the conformist pupils they called “ear’oles”. They expected to go into manual work where qualifications didn’t matter, and they did. Willis’s study is in detail in my post on Learning to Labour.

Máirtín Mac an Ghaill (1994), in his study of Parnell School, found a wider range of working-class responses than Willis suggested. He identified:

  1. The Macho Lads, who were hostile to school, much like Willis’s lads.
  2. The Academic Achievers, working-class boys who were doing well and tended to come from the upper end of the working class.
  3. The New Enterprisers, who focused on vocational subjects such as business and technology and were aiming for success rather than rejecting school.

Mac an Ghaill also showed how class and gender work together. Working-class boys were under pressure to express traditional anti-school masculinities. Middle-class boys were more likely to show their masculinity by competing in exams, though even they felt some pressure not to be seen trying too hard.

More on these studies, and on Lacey’s idea of polarisation, is in my post on pupil subcultures.

The hidden curriculum

The hidden curriculum is everything pupils learn at school that isn’t formally taught: attitudes to authority, punctuality, competition, what counts as good behaviour and good taste.

Marxists Bowles and Gintis argued that the hidden curriculum prepares working-class pupils for working-class jobs by teaching obedience and acceptance of hierarchy. This is their correspondence principle.

Pierre Bourdieu made a different argument. Schools are middle-class environments, run by teachers in a graduate profession, and the tastes, manners and ways of speaking they reward are middle-class ones. Middle-class pupils feel at home there without trying. Working-class pupils may feel they have to become someone else to fit in. This links straight to cultural capital.

The concept itself is covered in my post on the hidden curriculum and school ethos.

Evaluating in-school explanations

In-school explanations have real strengths:

  • They explain why pupils of similar ability can end up with different results, which home-based explanations struggle to do.
  • They don’t blame working-class families, unlike cultural deprivation theory.
  • They suggest schools can make a difference, which gives policy something to work with: mixed-ability teaching, careful setting decisions, and training on teacher expectations.

HOWEVER, there are serious limitations:

  • Labelling is too deterministic. Not every labelled pupil accepts the label. Some reject it and work harder to prove the teacher wrong.
  • Many of the classic studies are old, small and American. Becker interviewed teachers in Chicago in the early 1950s; Rist studied one kindergarten class. Even where effects are found, reviews suggest they are usually small.
  • Much of the gap is there before secondary school. The DfE’s disadvantage gap index shows a clear gap by the end of primary school, so secondary-school processes can’t be the whole story. See material deprivation and the class achievement statistics.
  • Home and school are hard to separate. Willis’s lads brought an anti-school working-class culture with them from home. Ball’s banding decisions used information that partly reflected what children had learned before they arrived.
  • Structural critics such as Marxists argue that interactionists ignore the wider system: teachers label pupils within schools judged on league tables, in a class-divided society.

The strongest conclusion is that home and school factors work together: middle-class advantage at home is turned into further advantage at school, and working-class disadvantage is compounded. There’s a full answer built on this argument in my social class and educational achievement essay plan.

How in-school factors come up in the exam

In-school factors come up on Paper 1 (7192/1) in two ways.

As 10-mark “analyse two ways” questions with an Item. Two recent examples:

  • June 2022, Q03: Applying material from Item A, analyse two ways in which relationships and processes within schools may lead to anti-school subcultures. [10 marks]
  • June 2023, Q03: Applying material from Item A, analyse two ways that the hidden curriculum may help to reproduce the social class structure. [10 marks]

For the first, labelling and banding (Ball) are two distinct routes into subcultures. For the second, the correspondence principle and Bourdieu’s middle-class school are two genuinely different mechanisms. Always take your two ways from the Item, and don’t pick two examples of the same thing.

As one side of a 30-mark essay on class differences in achievement. June 2018, Q04 asked: Applying material from Item B and your knowledge, evaluate sociological explanations of social class differences in educational achievement. [30 marks]. In-school factors are the obvious counterweight to home-based explanations in an answer like that.

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle, AQA A-level Sociology Paper 1

Revise Education for Paper 1

50 pages of mid-depth revision notes and 15 colour At a Glance sheets covering all eleven topics, plus 9 mind maps and 28 exam questions with model answers. Policy coverage runs right up to the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026.

Written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.

Signposting and Related Posts

This post has been written primarily for students studying the education topic, as part of the AQA’s A-Level Sociology course, especially the issue of social class differences in educational achievement.

For the home-based side of the debate, see material deprivation, cultural deprivation and cultural capital. For whether the system as a whole is fair, see meritocracy and education.

You can find the full set of notes on the sociology of education page.

Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com

Sources

Ball, S. (1981) Beachside Comprehensive: A Case-Study of Secondary Schooling. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Becker, H. S. (1952) Social-class variations in the teacher-pupil relationship. Journal of Educational Sociology, 25, 451–465.

Gillborn, D. and Youdell, D. (2000) Rationing Education: Policy, Practice, Reform and Equity. Buckingham: Open University Press.

Jussim, L. and Harber, K. D. (2005) Teacher expectations and self-fulfilling prophecies: knowns and unknowns, resolved and unresolved controversies. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 9(2), 131–155.

Keddie, N. (1971) Classroom knowledge. In Young, M. F. D. (ed.) Knowledge and Control: New Directions for the Sociology of Education. London: Macmillan.

Mac an Ghaill, M. (1994) The Making of Men: Masculinities, Sexualities and Schooling. Buckingham: Open University Press.

Rist, R. C. (1970) Student social class and teacher expectations: the self-fulfilling prophecy in ghetto education. Harvard Educational Review, 40(3), 411–451.

Rosenthal, R. and Jacobson, L. (1968) Pygmalion in the Classroom. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.

Willis, P. (1977) Learning to Labour: How Working Class Kids Get Working Class Jobs. Farnborough: Saxon House.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top