The 1988 Education Reform Act

Last Updated on November 2, 2026 by Karl Thompson

The 1988 Education Reform Act is the most important education policy you need to know for A-level sociology. Passed by Margaret Thatcher’s Conservative government (it received Royal Assent on 29 July 1988), it introduced the national curriculum and national testing, open enrolment, formula funding and local management of schools, grant-maintained schools and city technology colleges.

Together these policies created what sociologists call an education market, or ‘quasi-market’: schools competing with each other for pupils, with parents choosing between them. Every government since has kept the basic framework the Act put in place.

This post explains the thinking behind the Act, what it actually did (and what it is often wrongly credited with), the evidence on whether it raised standards, and the main criticisms. It’s part of the education module, examined on AQA Paper 1 (7192/1).

The thinking behind the 1988 Act: marketisation and parentocracy

The Act was shaped by the ideas of the New Right, which had a strong influence on the Conservative governments of 1979 to 1997. Two ideas matter most.

Marketisation means bringing market forces into education: making schools compete for pupils (and the funding that comes with them) in the same way that businesses compete for customers. The New Right argued that schools run by local authorities had no incentive to improve. Competition would reward good schools, which would attract more pupils and grow, and force poor schools to improve or close.

Parentocracy (‘rule by parents’) means giving parents the power to choose their child’s school. Marketisation only works if parents can choose, because parental choice is what makes schools compete. Parents need information to choose well, which is why testing, published results and inspection reports became so important.

A similar argument was made in the USA by Chubb and Moe in Politics, Markets and America’s Schools (1990): that state schools performed poorly because they were run by democratic, bureaucratic control rather than by parent choice and competition.

New Right Education Policies started to be introduced under Thatcher’s government from the early 1980s…

Marketisation as a concept, and the New Right and neoliberal perspectives behind it, are covered in more depth in my posts on the New Right’s view of education and the neoliberal perspective on education.

What the 1988 Education Reform Act did

The five main changes in the 1988 Act (Part I)

  1. The national curriculum, with assessment at the end of each key stage
  2. Open enrolment: schools had to admit pupils up to their capacity
  3. Local management of schools and formula funding
  4. Grant-maintained schools, which could opt out of local authority control
  5. City technology colleges

1. The national curriculum and national testing

Before 1988 there was very little central control over what state schools taught. The Act created a national curriculum for maintained (state) schools in England and Wales, made up of:

  • core subjects: English, maths and science (and Welsh in Welsh-speaking schools in Wales)
  • other foundation subjects: history, geography, technology, music, art and physical education, plus a modern foreign language from age 11

Schooling was divided into four key stages, ending at about age 7, 11, 14 and 16. The Act required arrangements for assessing pupils “at or near the end of each key stage”. These became the national curriculum tests known as SATs, with GCSEs at the end of key stage 4.

A common national curriculum and national tests meant that, for the first time, every state school’s results could be compared on the same measures. That is what made league tables possible a few years later.

2. Open enrolment

From 1980, parents had been able to express a preference for which school their child went to (Education Act 1980). But local authorities could still limit how many pupils a school took, often to keep less popular schools open.

The 1988 Act stopped this. Each school was given a ‘standard number’ based on its earlier admissions, and it could not set its intake below that number. Popular schools had to fill up to capacity, so parents’ preferences now had real consequences: a popular school grew, and a less popular one shrank.

League Tables today, accessible online!

3. Local management of schools and formula funding

Before 1988, local education authorities (LEAs) controlled school budgets and could give extra money per pupil to schools that were struggling. The Act required each LEA to delegate most of the budget to schools’ governing bodies (local management of schools), and to share it out by a formula that had to take account of “the number and ages of registered pupils” at each school. Other factors, such as the number of pupils with special educational needs, could be included.

Because most of the money now followed the pupil, every extra pupil brought extra funding and every lost pupil cost the school money. This is the mechanism that turned parental choice into competition.

4. Grant-maintained schools

The Act allowed schools to leave local authority control altogether, after a ballot of parents, and be funded directly by central government as grant-maintained schools. They ran their own budgets, staffing and admissions. Grant-maintained status was abolished by the School Standards and Framework Act 1998, and these schools became foundation schools, but the idea of state schools independent of the local authority came back on a much bigger scale with academies.

5. City technology colleges

The Act also allowed the government to make agreements to set up city technology colleges (and city colleges for the technology of the arts): new secondary schools in urban areas, outside local authority control and focused on science and technology. They are often seen as a forerunner of New Labour’s city academies.

The Act made other changes too, including abolishing the Inner London Education Authority (ILEA), but these five are the ones you need for the exam.

What the 1988 Act didn’t do: GCSEs, league tables and Ofsted

Three policies are often credited to the 1988 Act, but they came from elsewhere:

  • GCSEs were announced in 1984, first taught in 1986 and first examined in 1988, replacing O levels and CSEs. They were already on the way before the Act was passed.
  • League tables of school results built on the Act’s national testing, but secondary school league tables were first published in 1992. Their headline measure was the percentage of pupils getting five or more good GCSEs (A* to C).
  • Ofsted (the Office for Standards in Education) was created by the Education (Schools) Act 1992, and its first school inspections took place in September 1993.

All three were part of the same marketisation programme, though, and examiners will accept them as marketisation policies. Just don’t say the 1988 Act introduced them. League tables have their own post: are league tables good for education?

The declining power of local education authorities

Taken together, open enrolment, formula funding, local management of schools and grant-maintained status shifted power away from LEAs in two directions: down to parents and headteachers, and up to central government, which now decided what was taught and how schools were tested.

LEAs lost control over how many pupils each school took and over most of the money. That set the scene for what came later: successful schools expanding, failing schools being taken over, and eventually most secondary schools becoming academies outside local authority control altogether.

Did the 1988 Act raise standards?

The strongest evidence for the New Right is that exam results rose steadily after 1988.

MeasureYearResult
GCSE entries graded C or above (UK, all subjects)198842.5%
200257.9%
201169.8%
201468.8%
Pupils getting five or more GCSEs at A* to C (England)1992/9341.2%
2000/0150.0%

Sources: Smithers (2015), from JCQ results; DfES (2002).

Supporters of the Act also point out that no government since 1988, Conservative or Labour, has dismantled its basic framework. New Labour, the Coalition and later governments all kept the national curriculum, testing, league tables, parental choice and per-pupil funding.

HOWEVER, there are good reasons to be cautious:

  • Correlation isn’t causation. Results might have risen anyway, for other reasons: more pupils staying on, more spending, changing attitudes to qualifications.
  • GCSEs were new in 1988. Rising results in a new exam may partly reflect teachers and pupils getting used to it.
  • Grade inflation. Grades rose almost every year from 1988 to 2011. From 2012, the exams regulator Ofqual, suspecting considerable grade inflation, began holding results steady using a ‘comparable outcomes’ approach. If grades were getting easier to achieve, rising results don’t prove rising standards.
  • Rising averages can hide widening gaps. The criticisms below are mostly about who benefited.

Criticisms of the 1988 Education Reform Act

League tables and testing distort teaching

Once schools are judged on test results, they have an incentive to put those results first. Critics argue that schools ‘teach to the test’, spend more time on tested subjects such as English and maths at the expense of the arts, and focus on what is measured rather than on wider learning.

Gillborn and Youdell found teachers concentrating their efforts on pupils on the borderline of a grade C, because those pupils could improve the school’s league table position, which they called the ‘A-to-C economy’. See Gillborn and Youdell: Rationing Education.

League tables may also give parents a misleading picture. Leckie and Goldstein, statisticians at the University of Bristol, found that differences between schools’ results are driven largely by differences in their intakes, and that once uncertainty is taken into account, very few schools can be reliably separated from the average. They concluded that league tables have very little to offer parents choosing a school.

Testing and pupils’ wellbeing

A National Education Union survey of 1,200 primary school teachers found that nine in ten believed SATs were detrimental to pupils’ wellbeing and mental health, and 86% said SATs lowered the quality of primary education by narrowing the curriculum. Bear in mind that this is a teaching union’s survey of teachers’ views, not a measure of pupils’ wellbeing.

Middle-class parents have more effective choice

Choice is only real if you can act on it, and some parents are much better placed than others:

  • Selection by mortgage. Houses near the most popular schools cost more, so better-off families can buy their way into the catchment area.
  • Transport. Families with cars and flexible working hours can choose schools further away.
  • Cultural capital. Middle-class parents are more confident dealing with schools, better at researching them and using their networks, and more likely to appeal. Gewirtz, Ball and Bowe (1995) described them as ‘privileged/skilled choosers’, while many working-class parents were ‘disconnected choosers’ who sent their children to the nearest school.

For the research on this, see my post on unequal parental choice, and on cultural capital and educational achievement.

Cream-skimming

Cream-skimming means that popular, oversubscribed schools can select the pupils most likely to do well, who are disproportionately middle class. Those pupils improve the school’s results, which makes it more popular still. Its opposite is sometimes called silt-shifting: schools trying to avoid or offload pupils who might pull their results down, such as those with special educational needs or behavioural problems.

Formula funding makes this worse: a school that cream-skims gains both results and money, and the schools left with the pupils nobody else selected lose both.

Polarisation and ‘sink schools’

The result, critics argue, is polarisation: the most popular schools get better and more oversubscribed, while the least popular lose pupils, money and staff, and end up with the highest concentrations of disadvantaged pupils. These are sometimes called ‘sink schools’. Inequality of educational opportunity increases rather than decreases.

Labelling and failing pupils

More testing means more pupils being labelled as failures from an early age, with the risk of a self-fulfilling prophecy. Pupils in schools at the bottom of the league tables can end up labelled by where they go to school, as well as by their own results.

Exam question: AQA June 2023, Question 02

The 1988 Act and marketisation come up regularly on Paper 1. This is a real AQA question:

AQA A-level Sociology 7192/1, June 2023, Question 02

Outline three criticisms of marketisation policies in education. [6 marks]

The mark scheme

Mark scheme available here.

Outline three criticisms of marketisation policies in education.
Two marks for each of three appropriate criticisms clearly outlined, or one mark for
each appropriate criticism partially outlined.
Answers may include:

  • marketisation policies assume that league tables can measure school performance (1 mark); league tables use a narrow range of data ignoring the wider context (+1 mark)
  • assume competition between schools is desirable (1 mark); it may discourage cooperation between schools in an area (+1 mark)
  • increased testing can have negative effects (1 mark); it can lead to labelling and the creation of self-fulfilling prophecies (+1 mark)
  • marketisation policies may lead to unfair selection practices (1 mark); leads to
    less popular schools going into a spiral of decline which adversely affects their pupils (+1 mark)
  • assume competition between schools creates a meritocracy (1 mark); middle- class parents can use their cultural capital to ensure their children succeed (+1 mark)
  • fewer resources are available for supporting learning directly (1 mark); due to time and money spent on marketing and publicity (+1 mark).

Other relevant material should be credited.
No marks for no relevant points.

What the examiners said

AQA’s report on the June 2023 exam said:

“There were a wide range of answers to this question. Many students took the approach of criticising marketisation policies generally. Students commonly referred to the ‘myth of parentocracy’ and/or that these policies may have led to greater inequalities as some schools may select students from some social groups over others. Other students referred to criticisms of specific marketisation policies, for example, that league tables may produce a misleading and inaccurate picture of the success of a school. Some less successful students drifted into criticisms of privatisation in education without any success of linking this in any way to marketisation. Some others referred to more general and non-relevant policies such as the tripartite system.”

Model answer

1. Middle-class parents have more effective choice. Marketisation assumes all parents can choose, but middle-class parents have more economic capital (they can afford houses in the catchment areas of popular schools) and more cultural capital (they know how to research schools and work the admissions system). As a result, parental choice reproduces class inequality rather than creating a meritocracy.

2. League tables give a narrow and misleading picture of schools. League tables measure only exam results, which mainly reflect a school’s intake rather than the quality of its teaching. They also push schools to teach to the test and to focus on pupils at the borderline of key grades, as in Gillborn and Youdell’s ‘A-to-C economy’, at the expense of other pupils.

3. Competition leads to polarisation. Popular schools can cream-skim the most able pupils and, because funding follows pupils, gain money as well as results. Less popular schools lose pupils and funding and end up with the most disadvantaged pupils, so the gap between the best and worst schools widens.

KT’s Commentary

Each point names a criticism in the first sentence and then explains it in the second, which is what gets the second mark. Notice that all three are criticisms of marketisation: the examiners’ report warns against drifting into privatisation, and against older policies such as the tripartite system, which isn’t a marketisation policy at all.

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle

Revise Education properly

Notes at two depths, so you can start early and finish fast — mid-depth notes to learn and consolidate from, and one-page summary sheets for the last fortnight.

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle, AQA A-level Sociology Paper 1

Sociology of Education
50 pages of mid-depth notes, 15 colour At a Glance sheets, 9 mind maps and 28 exam questions with model answers. Policy coverage to the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026.

A-Level Sociology Revision Mega Bundle, all six modules

Or take all six modules
Education plus Families, Beliefs, the Media, Crime and Deviance, and Theory and Methods. Over 450 pages, 110 sheets, 71 mind maps and 88 exam questions. Bought separately they come to more than £35.

Written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.

Signposting and Related Posts

This post has been written for students studying the education module as part of AQA A-level sociology. Education policy is usually taught in historical order:

Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com

Sources
  • AQA (2023) Report on the Examination: A-level Sociology 7192/1, June 2023.
  • Chubb, J. E. and Moe, T. M. (1990) Politics, Markets and America’s Schools, Brookings Institution Press.
  • Department for Education and Skills (2002) GCSE/GNVQ and GCE A/AS/VCE/AGNVQ Examination Results 2000/01 – England, Statistical Bulletin.
  • Education Act 1980, s.6.
  • Education Reform Act 1988 (legislation.gov.uk).
  • Elliott, A. (2012) Twenty Years Inspecting English Schools: Ofsted 1992–2012, RISE review.
  • Gewirtz, S., Ball, S. and Bowe, R. (1995) Markets, Choice and Equity in Education, Open University Press.
  • Gillborn, D. and Youdell, D. (2000) Rationing Education, Open University Press.
  • Leckie, G. and Goldstein, H. (2016) The Evolution of School League Tables in England 1992–2016, Bristol Working Papers in Education 02/2016.
  • Leckie, G. and Goldstein, H. The Limitations of Using School League Tables to Inform School Choice, University of Bristol.
  • Oates, T. (2021) ‘What have GCSEs ever done for us?’, Cambridge Assessment, 28 October.
  • Smithers, A. (2015) GCSE Trends 1988–2016, Centre for Education and Employment Research, University of Buckingham.
  • UK Parliament, The Education Reform Act 1988 (Living Heritage).

5 thoughts on “The 1988 Education Reform Act”

  1. Hi do you have the name of the textbook this information was from as I need to reference for my assignment
    thanks 🙂

  2. Hi Karl, thanks for this – really useful. Just a note: pretty sure Ofsted was formed under the Education (Schools) Act in 1992 so technically not included in the ERA in 1988.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top