Last Updated on November 16, 2026 by Karl Thompson
This is the 10-mark “outline and explain” question (no Item) from the Families and Households section of the June 2017 AQA A-level Sociology Paper 2 (7192/2), Topics in Sociology.
In this post you’ll find the question, how it’s marked, what a good answer needs, a model answer, and a marked student answer with the examiner’s commentary.
NB – if you’d like to attempt this question BEFORE looking at the answers below, you can review the topic first: see my posts on how childhood has changed over time and on gender roles and the domestic division of labour.
The question (no Item!)
Outline and explain two ways in which changing gender roles within the family may have affected children’s experience of childhood (10)
How the question is marked
| Assessment objective | What it rewards | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| AO1 | Knowledge and understanding | 5 |
| AO2 | Application | 3 |
| AO3 | Analysis and evaluation | 2 |
| Total | 10 | |
The marks are split the same way on every “outline and explain” 10-mark question. In summary, the top band (8–10 marks) goes to answers that identify two clearly different ways, explain each one in depth with accurate sociological knowledge, apply it directly to the question, and analyse it, for example by explaining the consequences or why the effect varies between families.
Note: the mark scheme rewards analysis on this question, not evaluation. Two points developed and explained beat one point and a criticism of it. The 10-mark questions with an Item (“Applying material from Item C, analyse two…”) are different: they reward evaluation as well.
The Mark Scheme:

What a good answer needs
The question has two parts, and you need to link them every time:
- Changing gender roles within the family – for example, more women (especially mothers) in paid work, more involved fathers, more joint conjugal roles.
- Children’s experience of childhood – what has actually changed for children as a result.
The commonest mistake is to write two good paragraphs about changing gender roles and only mention children in the last sentence. Every paragraph should be about children.
A model answer
One way is that mothers’ increased involvement in paid work has changed how much of their childhood children spend with their parents and with other carers.
Women’s roles in the family have changed dramatically since the 1950s, when Parsons described the mother’s role as the “expressive” one, centred on caring for children at home. Today most mothers work: the employment rate of mothers with dependent children in the UK rose from 66.5% in 2002 to 75.6% in 2021 (ONS). Women are also having children later, with mothers’ average age at childbirth now over 31, and having fewer of them.
This has changed children’s experience in several ways. Children grow up with fewer siblings, and with parents who can invest more money in each child. Many more children spend part of their early childhood in formal childcare, such as nurseries and childminders, or being looked after by grandparents, so they’re socialised by a wider range of adults than in the past. The government has expanded funded childcare, partly to help mothers work, so for most children some form of early education now starts well before school.
Analysis: the effect varies by class. Better-off dual-earner families can pay for high-quality childcare and activities, while lower-paid parents may rely on informal care or struggle to cover the cost. And some critics, such as Sue Palmer, argue that long working hours mean some children get less parental time than they need, which she sees as one cause of “toxic childhood”.
A second way is that fathers taking a more active role in the family has given children closer relationships with their fathers and less gender-stereotyped socialisation.
Young and Willmott (1973) argued that families were becoming more “symmetrical”, with couples moving from segregated to joint conjugal roles and sharing domestic tasks and leisure more equally. Time-use research supports part of this: Dotti Sani and Treas (2016) found that fathers in the UK and other Western countries spent considerably more time on childcare in 2012 than in 1965. Esther Dermott (2008) argues that modern fathers value an emotionally close, “intimate” relationship with their children, rather than seeing themselves mainly as breadwinners.
For children, this can mean a closer, more emotional relationship with their father than previous generations had. It may also change how children are socialised into gender roles. Ann Oakley argued that children learn gender through “canalisation” (being channelled towards gender-appropriate toys and activities) and “manipulation”. Where parents share roles more equally, children see both parents caring and working, so they may be less likely to be socialised into traditional, stereotyped roles.
Analysis: the change may be smaller than it looks. ONS time-use data show that mothers still do more childcare than fathers, and feminists argue that fathers tend to do the “fun” parts of childcare while mothers keep the responsibility for organising children’s lives. So for many children, the experience of a symmetrical family is still more of an ideal than a reality.
A marked student answer from AQA (8/10)
This answer comes from AQA’s published student responses with examiner commentary, and was awarded 8 out of 10. It’s reproduced exactly as AQA published it, including the student’s mistakes.
Student Response:
One way is with the changing roles of women in society, where women are more likely to want to pursue a career before starting a family, with less stigma attached to them, women have taken on more aspects of the instrumental role which Parsons had said traditionally rested with men. This has meant a decrease in family size since the 1970s from 3.2 children to 2, as women in full time employment have children later in life. It has also led to a mono-child society and a ‘fuller experience’ of childhood as parents have more money to spend on one child.
As second change is associated with Young and Wilmott’s symmetrical families – couples have moved from segregated to joint conjugal roles where they share leisure time and chores much more equally than before. This is also related to the rise of the new man who offers more emotional support. This means children are no longer socialised into traditional gender roles and will not experience canalisation like Oakley suggested – e.g. boys are less likely to be given typical boys toys sjuch as guns and socialised into typical traditional male traits such as aggression.
Examiner Commentary: (8/10 marks)

Source: AQA [YEAR TO CONFIRM], Student responses with examiner commentary, AS and A-level Sociology 7191 and 7192. Reproduced here for educational purposes.
Families and Households Revision Bundle
Revise Families and Households properly
Notes at two depths, so you can start early and finish fast — mid-depth notes to learn and build essay content from, and one-page summary sheets for the last fortnight.
Written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.
Signposting
- The June 2017 families and households paper – how I would have answered the whole paper.
- AQA A-level Sociology Paper 2: families and households exam advice – the question types and how to answer them.
- Outline and explain two ways in which increased life expectancy may have affected the experience of childhood – another childhood 10-marker, from June 2022.
- Gender roles, domestic labour and power relationships – the background on changing gender roles.
For more A-level sociology exam questions and answers, see my page on exams, short answer questions and essays.
Sources
- AQA (2017) A-level Sociology 7192/2 Paper 2 Topics in Sociology, June 2017, question paper. Copyright © 2017 AQA and its licensors. All rights reserved.
- Dermott, E. (2008) Intimate Fatherhood: A Sociological Analysis.
- Dotti Sani, G. M. and Treas, J. (2016) “Educational gradients in parents’ child-care time across countries, 1965–2012”, Journal of Marriage and Family.
- Office for National Statistics (2022) Families and the labour market, UK: 2021; Births in England and Wales: 2025.
- Young, M. and Willmott, P. (1973) The Symmetrical Family.

