How do teachers teach ‘British Values’?

Last Updated on October 28, 2026 by Karl Thompson

Schools in England have been required to promote ‘fundamental British values’ since November 2014, when the Department for Education published guidance on promoting them as part of pupils’ spiritual, moral, social and cultural (SMSC) development. The values are democracy, the rule of law, individual liberty, and mutual respect and tolerance of those with different faiths and beliefs.

At first sight, this requirement seems to support the functionalist view of education, which holds that one of the functions of education is to promote value consensus.

HOWEVER, that may be a simplistic understanding, according to the research outlined below. Some schools may present British values in a very traditional way, which could alienate pupils who haven’t been brought up with those traditions. In other words, the way British values are taught in some schools may not be an effective way of creating value consensus in a diverse, multicultural society.

Recent research on how teachers teach British values

Professor Carol Vincent, of the UCL Institute of Education, researched how schools and teachers interpret ‘fundamental British values’. Between 2016 and 2018 she carried out 56 interviews with teachers and 49 observations, mostly of lessons and assemblies, in nine case study schools: four primary and five secondary, mostly in Greater London. Her findings were published in her book Tea and the Queen? Fundamental British Values, Schools and Citizenship (2019).

Why do schools have to teach them?

The requirement to promote fundamental British values came about because of concerns over social cohesion and ‘Britishness’, and in particular as a response to the ‘Trojan Horse’ affair of 2014, when there were allegations of a co-ordinated attempt to introduce an Islamist ethos into several schools in Birmingham. A government-commissioned report into the allegations, by Peter Clarke, was published in July 2014.

The requirement is closely related to the government’s counter-terrorism strategy and the Prevent duty. See the Prevent agenda: arguments for and against.

The government’s guidance gives schools only limited detail on how, exactly, they should promote the values, so how do teachers understand this responsibility, and how do they put it into practice?

Were the teachers supportive?

According to Vincent, teachers were generally supportive of the values themselves, but some disliked the word ‘tolerance’, because it suggests grudgingly putting up with each other rather than celebrating diversity and mutual respect. Some teachers were much more cynical about the requirement.

How did schools fit it in?

Most of Vincent’s case study schools did not teach British values explicitly. Instead, they folded them into things they were already doing: a school council to show democracy, school rules to show the rule of law, and so on. Some schools used PSHE, religious education lessons and assemblies to address them more directly.

The problem with this approach is that it doesn’t open up much discussion of what the values mean. Vincent also raised questions about school councils themselves, such as whether only the ‘good kids’ are heard.

Representing Britishness through symbols

Vincent described in interviews how some schools represented Britain through traditional symbols such as the Royal Family, even though support for the monarchy is not one of the fundamental British values. Representing Britishness through symbols like this can give a narrow, fixed picture of what it means to be British, and can exclude pupils whose families don’t share those traditions.

Dangerous conversations

Many teachers were anxious about how to handle controversial issues that came up in discussion around the values. Vincent found that teachers saw topics such as Brexit, migration, terrorism and media portrayals of Muslims as potentially ‘dangerous conversations’. Limited curriculum time, performance pressures and uncertainty about how to stay neutral made them hard to handle, and teachers sometimes avoided them.

How could they be taught more effectively?

Vincent argues that citizenship education needs more status, more time for pupils to discuss what citizenship and British values mean, and more training for teachers on handling difficult issues.

Evaluation and links

The research is a useful example for evaluating the functionalist idea of value consensus, and for the debate about whether education policy has become more assimilationist (see policies to combat racism in schools). For British values as a form of social control, see education and social control.

Bear in mind that the study is based on nine schools, mostly in London, so it may not be typical of schools across the country.

Find out more: Carol Vincent discussed her research on BBC Radio 4’s Thinking Allowed.

Sources
  • Vincent, C. (2019) Tea and the Queen? Fundamental British Values, Schools and Citizenship. Bristol: Policy Press.
  • Vincent, C. (2019) ‘Cohesion, citizenship and coherence: schools’ responses to the British values policy’, British Journal of Sociology of Education, 40(1), 17–32.
  • Department for Education (2014) Promoting fundamental British values as part of SMSC in schools (November 2014).
  • Clarke, P. (2014) Report into allegations concerning Birmingham schools arising from the ‘Trojan Horse’ letter.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top