Basil Bernstein: Restricted and Elaborated Speech Codes

Last Updated on November 1, 2026 by Karl Thompson

Basil Bernstein argued that social classes tend to use language in different ways, which he called speech codes. Working-class children were more likely to be limited to a restricted code, while middle-class children could also use the elaborated code, which is the language of school. This gave middle-class children an advantage in education. The key points are:

  1. The restricted code is context-bound: its meaning depends on shared understanding between speakers.
  2. The elaborated code spells meanings out, so they can be understood without the context.
  3. Schools teach, test and value the elaborated code, so children who arrive already using it are at an advantage.
  4. Bernstein insisted the restricted code was not inferior or a sign of “linguistic deprivation”, although his work was widely read as if it were.
  5. Critics such as William Labov argued that working-class and Black American speech was different, not deficient.

Bernstein’s work is part of the topic of social class differences in educational achievement within the sociology of education, examined on AQA Paper 1 (7192/1). It is often taught as part of cultural deprivation theory, although, as you’ll see below, that isn’t quite fair to Bernstein.

Who was Basil Bernstein?

Basil Bernstein (1924–2000) was a British sociologist who spent most of his career at the Institute of Education in London. He developed his ideas about language and social class in a series of papers from the late 1950s onwards, many of them collected in Class, Codes and Control (Volume 1, 1971). His later work moved on to how schools organise knowledge, but A-level sociology mainly uses his early work on speech codes.

The restricted and elaborated speech codes

A comparison of the restricted and elaborated speech code

The restricted code

The restricted code uses a more limited vocabulary and simpler grammar, with shorter sentences, few adjectives and adverbs, and meaning often conveyed by gesture and tone of voice.

The restricted code operates in terms of particularistic meanings: it is tied to a specific context, and what is said only fully makes sense to people who share that context. It is a sort of shorthand between close friends, family members or partners who have a shared understanding of the situation, so there is no need to spell out meanings in detail.

The elaborated code

The elaborated code has a wider vocabulary and uses more complex grammatical structures. It spells out meanings explicitly, so it operates in terms of universalistic meanings: listeners do not need to share the speaker’s context to understand what is being said.

Restricted codeElaborated code
Vocabulary and grammarNarrower vocabulary, simpler grammar, shorter sentencesWider vocabulary, more complex grammar
MeaningParticularistic: depends on shared contextUniversalistic: understandable without the context
Typical settingClose relationships with shared understandingFormal settings such as school, where meanings must be explained
Who uses it (Bernstein)Everyone, but working-class children more likely to be limited to itMiddle-class children more likely to have access to it as well

Notice the last row. Bernstein didn’t argue that middle-class people never use the restricted code. Everyone uses it with family and friends. His point was that middle-class children were more likely to be able to switch into the elaborated code as well.

Hawkins: the picture-story study

The best-known evidence for the codes comes from P. R. Hawkins (1969), whose research Bernstein used to illustrate the two codes. Hawkins studied the speech of 124 middle-class and 139 working-class five-year-olds in London. One task asked children to tell the story shown in a series of four pictures. (In the version usually given in textbooks, boys are playing football, the ball breaks a window, a man shouts at them and they run away.)

Working-class children were significantly more likely to use pronouns such as “he”, “they” and “it” that referred directly to things in the pictures, so their story only made sense to a listener who could see the pictures. Middle-class children used more nouns and noun phrases, so their story could be understood without the pictures. In Bernstein’s terms, the working-class versions were more context-bound and the middle-class versions more universalistic.

How speech codes affect educational achievement

Bernstein argued that formal education is conducted in the elaborated code. Teachers explain, textbooks are written and exams are set in it, and pupils are expected to use it to show what they know. So children who arrive at school already using the elaborated code are at an automatic advantage, while children limited to the restricted code have to learn the code of the school before they can show what they understand.

The elaborated code also matters because it is the language of generalisation and abstract ideas, which become more important as children move up through school. A child who can only explain things in context-bound ways may find it harder to handle the abstract concepts that higher-level study demands.

This is why Bernstein’s work is useful in essays: it is one of the few explanations that connects home background to what happens inside the classroom. Differences in socialisation at home only become an educational disadvantage because the school values one code over another.

Was Bernstein a cultural deprivation theorist?

Bernstein’s work is often taught as part of cultural deprivation theory, and in the 1960s and 1970s it was widely read as showing that working-class children were “linguistically deprived”. Bernstein himself rejected that reading. He argued that the restricted code should not be equated with linguistic deprivation or deficiency, or with being non-verbal. It was a different way of using language, suited to different social relationships.

In 1970 he published a short article in New Society called “Education cannot compensate for society”. As the title suggests, he was sceptical that compensatory education programmes could make up for inequalities rooted in wider society, and he later complained that his ideas had been misinterpreted.

So there are two ways of reading Bernstein, and the difference is a good analysis point in an exam:

  • The cultural deprivation reading: working-class children lack the language needed for success, so the problem lies in the working-class home.
  • The cultural capital reading: working-class language is different, not inferior, and the problem lies in a school system that rewards one code over another. This is close to Bourdieu’s argument about cultural capital.

Evaluating Bernstein

Strengths

It links home and school. Bernstein explains how differences in socialisation at home turn into differences in achievement at school, rather than treating home and school as separate.

There is supporting evidence. Hawkins’s study found clear class differences in how five-year-olds used language, in the direction Bernstein predicted.

It doesn’t have to blame working-class families. Read the way Bernstein intended, the theory locates the problem in the school’s preference for the elaborated code, not in any deficiency of working-class speech.

Criticisms

Labov: different, not deficient. The American linguist William Labov, in his essay “The logic of non-standard English”, analysed the speech of Black American young people and argued that its logic was not inferior to middle-class speech, which could be wordy without being any clearer. He also criticised the test situations used to judge the children’s language. The essay was reprinted in Nell Keddie’s collection Tinker, Tailor… The Myth of Cultural Deprivation (1973), which argued that the whole idea of cultural deprivation was a myth.

It is often read as a deficit theory. Whatever Bernstein intended, his work was used to support the idea that working-class children were linguistically deprived. The British educationist Harold Rosen wrote one of the best-known critiques, Language and Class: A Critical Look at the Theories of Basil Bernstein.

Class is defined vaguely. Bernstein sometimes refers to the working class and sometimes to the lower working class, and puts all non-manual workers into the middle class, ignoring variation within the middle classes.

Limited examples. Bernstein gave relatively few concrete examples of the two codes, which makes it hard to show clearly that they exist in the form he described.

It is dated. The research was carried out with children in the 1960s, when class differences in work and community life were sharper than they are now.

Language, ethnicity and schooling: the Ebonics debate

A related debate in the USA shows how the same questions apply to ethnicity. On 18 December 1996 the school board in Oakland, California, passed a resolution recognising the speech of African American pupils, which it called “Ebonics”, as their primary language, and proposing a programme that would use it to help pupils learn Standard English. The decision was highly controversial. For sociologists, it raised the same question as Labov’s work: should schools treat a group’s way of speaking as a deficiency to be corrected, or as a different language variety to be built on?

Bernstein in the exam

Bernstein is most useful in two kinds of question:

  • Short outline questions on factors outside school that affect class differences in achievement, such as AQA June 2020, Q01: “Outline two factors external to schools that may affect social class differences in educational achievement.” [4 marks] Speech codes are a creditable factor, as long as you explain how they affect achievement.
  • 30-mark essays on class differences or cultural factors. AQA’s June 2023 Q04 asked students to evaluate the importance of cultural factors in explaining patterns of educational achievement, and its Item said that “differences in primary socialisation may mean that some groups find it easier to engage with the culture of the school”. Bernstein’s speech codes are a direct way to apply that sentence. See my answer to evaluate the importance of cultural factors in explaining patterns of educational achievement.

In an essay, the two readings of Bernstein give you a ready-made evaluation point: use him as evidence for cultural deprivation, then point out that Bernstein himself rejected that interpretation, which takes you neatly into cultural capital theory.

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle

If you like this sort of thing, then you might like my sociology of education revision notes bundle, written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification. It contains the following:

  1. 34 pages of revision notes
  2. mind maps in pdf and png format – 9 in total, covering various topics within the sociology of education
  3. short answer exam practice questions and exemplar answers
  4. how to write sociology essays, including 7 specific templates and model answers on the sociology of education
Signposting and Related Posts

This post has been written primarily for students studying the education topic, as part of the AQA’s A-Level Sociology course, especially the issue of social class differences in educational achievement.

Bernstein is usually taught alongside cultural deprivation theory, and his work leads naturally into cultural capital theory. For the other main home-based explanation, see material deprivation.

You can find the full set of notes on the sociology of education page.

Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com

Sources

Bernstein, B. (1970) Education cannot compensate for society. New Society, 26 February 1970.

Bernstein, B. (1971) Class, Codes and Control, Volume 1: Theoretical Studies Towards a Sociology of Language. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Hawkins, P. R. (1969) Social class, the nominal group and reference. Language and Speech.

Keddie, N. (ed.) (1973) Tinker, Tailor… The Myth of Cultural Deprivation. Harmondsworth: Penguin Education. Includes Labov, W. “The logic of non-standard English”.

Oakland Unified School District Board of Education (1996) Resolution on Ebonics, 18 December 1996 (full text published by Education Week).

Rosen, H. (1974) Language and Class: A Critical Look at the Theories of Basil Bernstein. 3rd edn. Bristol: Falling Wall Press.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top