Selection Policies in Education

Last Updated on November 2, 2026 by Karl Thompson

Selection policies decide which pupils go to which schools. Schools can select pupils by academic ability (as grammar schools do), by aptitude in a subject, by religious faith, or by where they live. Even schools that don’t officially select at all can end up with intakes that are sorted by social class.

This post answers two questions:

  1. How do schools select pupils? By ability, aptitude, faith, catchment area, and covertly by social class.
  2. What does selection do to equality of educational opportunity? On most of the evidence, it benefits the middle classes.

Selection is part of the education policy topic in the education module, examined on AQA Paper 1 (7192/1). It has come up as a real exam question: see the June 2019 question at the end of this post. For every era of policy on one page, see my education policies summary.

Selection by ability: the tripartite system

The Education Act 1944 made free secondary education available to all, and required it to suit pupils’ different “ages, abilities and aptitudes”. The Act itself didn’t say how. Ministry of Education guidance after the war set out three types of secondary school:

  • Grammar schools, for pupils suited to an academic, book-based education.
  • Technical schools, for pupils with an aptitude for science, maths or practical subjects heading into industry or commerce. Few were ever built.
  • Secondary modern schools, for the majority, with a more practical education.

Which school a child went to was decided by the 11-plus exam. This is the tripartite system, and it is the clearest example of selection by ability in British education. The idea behind it was that a child’s ability was fixed and could be measured at 11. For more on the tripartite system, see my education policies summary.

Criticisms of the tripartite system

  • Ability isn’t fixed at 11. ‘Late developers’ who failed the 11-plus lost the chance of an academic education and the qualifications that went with it.
  • Labelling. Pupils who failed the 11-plus and went to secondary moderns were, in effect, labelled as failures at 11, with the risk of a self-fulfilling prophecy.
  • Class inequality. Middle-class children were more likely to pass the 11-plus and go to grammar schools, gain qualifications and move into well-paid jobs. Working-class children were more likely to go to secondary moderns. The system reproduced class inequality rather than reducing it.
  • No ‘parity of esteem’. The three types of school were meant to be equal but different. In practice, grammar schools had far higher status.

Comprehensive schools

In 1965, the Labour government’s Circular 10/65 (12 July 1965) requested local education authorities to prepare and submit plans to reorganise secondary education on comprehensive lines: one type of school for all pupils, with no selection by ability at 11.

It was a request, not a law, and selection was never completely abolished. The number of state grammar schools peaked at 1,298 in 1964, when around a quarter of state secondary pupils went to one. It nearly halved in the following decade as most areas went comprehensive. But some areas kept selection. In January 2019 there were 163 grammar schools in England, with about 176,000 pupils, and 11 local authorities were classed as highly selective (25% or more of their state secondary places in selective schools).

The School Standards and Framework Act 1998 means that no new grammar schools can open, and existing schools can’t introduce new selection by ability. Grammar schools that already existed can continue. For the arguments about whether they should, see my post on grammar schools.

Selection since the 1988 Education Reform Act

The 1988 Education Reform Act introduced open enrolment: popular schools had to take pupils up to their capacity, and parents could apply to any school. The most popular schools became oversubscribed, with more applicants than places, so they needed rules for deciding who gets in.

Today those rules are set by the School Admissions Code, which all state-funded schools in England must follow. The most common oversubscription criteria are:

  1. Distance or catchment area: children who live closer to the school, or inside a set area, get priority.
  2. Siblings: children with a brother or sister already at the school get priority.
  3. Faith: schools with a religious character may give priority by faith when they are oversubscribed. See my post on faith schools.
  4. Aptitude: schools may select up to 10% of their intake by aptitude in sport, the performing arts, the visual arts or modern foreign languages (and design and technology or IT, but only in schools that already selected this way from 2007/08).
  5. Disadvantage: schools may give priority to children eligible for the pupil premium, early years pupil premium or service premium.

The Code also bans some things. Schools must not interview children or parents, give priority according to parents’ occupation, marital, financial or educational status, ask for financial contributions, or use uniform and trip policies that discourage parents from applying. Only designated grammar schools may select their whole intake by high academic ability.

Types of school in England today: who can select?

Type of schoolCan it select by ability?How places are usually decided
Comprehensive schools (local authority maintained schools and most academies)NoOversubscription criteria in the Admissions Code: distance, siblings, sometimes aptitude (up to 10%) or pupil premium priority
Grammar schoolsYes, their whole intakeAn entrance test (the 11-plus) in the areas that kept selection
Partially selective schoolsYes, a proportion of their intakeOnly where this already happened before 1997/98, and no more than then
Faith schoolsNoMay give priority by faith when oversubscribed
Independent (private) schoolsYes (they set their own admissions)Fees, and often entrance exams and interviews. The Admissions Code doesn’t apply

Selection by the back door

Comprehensive schools don’t select by ability, but sociologists argue that selection by social class still goes on in other ways.

Selection by mortgage

Where distance or catchment area decides who gets in, house prices near the most popular schools rise. Over time, only better-off families can afford to live close enough. This is known as selection by mortgage: the school doesn’t choose by class, but the housing market does it for them. See my post on unequal parental choice.

Covert selection

In a 2007 report for the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR), Sarah Tough and Richard Brooks argued that the admissions system was causing segregation by class and ability between schools. They used the term covert selection for the ways some schools shaped their intakes without openly selecting, such as publishing complex or intimidating admissions literature that was hard for parents with poor literacy to understand.

They found this was much more likely in schools that controlled their own admissions. Among faith schools, 38% of voluntary-aided schools (which run their own admissions) were in the most unrepresentative 10% of schools, compared with 4% of voluntary-controlled schools (where the local authority runs admissions). They also cited Sutton Trust research (2006) showing that just 5.8% of pupils at the top 200 comprehensives were eligible for free school meals, against 13.7% in their local areas.

Interviews have since been banned, and the Admissions Code now forbids uniform policies that put parents off applying. Whether the Code fully prevents covert selection is harder to say: the most effective form, selection by mortgage, happens outside the school gates.

Does selection reduce or increase inequality?

Arguments for selection. Supporters, including many on the New Right, argue that selection by ability is meritocratic: it gives able children from any background an academic education, and lets parents choose schools that suit their children. Grammar schools are sometimes described as a ‘ladder of opportunity’ for bright working-class children.

Arguments against selection. Critics argue that, in practice, selection benefits the middle classes:

  • Few disadvantaged pupils get into grammar schools. In 2019, 3% of grammar school pupils were eligible for and claiming free school meals, compared with 15% at non-selective schools.
  • Middle-class parents can pay for tutoring for entrance tests, buy houses in the right catchment areas, and use their cultural capital to navigate the admissions system.
  • Pupils who aren’t selected can be labelled as failures, and the schools they go to lose able pupils.

Policies that push the other way. Since schools may now give priority to children eligible for the pupil premium, admissions can be used to widen access as well as narrow it. But this is optional, not compulsory.

Independent schools

Independent (private) schools are the most selective of all, because places depend first on parents’ ability to pay. In January 2026, the 1,455 schools in the Independent Schools Council taught 526,611 pupils. Since 1 January 2025, private school fees have been subject to VAT at 20%. For the arguments, see my post on arguments for and against private schools.

Outline two criticisms of schools selecting pupils by ability

This is a real AQA exam question:

AQA A-level Sociology 7192/1, June 2019, Question 01

Outline two criticisms of schools selecting pupils by ability. [4 marks]

Model answer

1. Selection by ability reproduces class inequality. Middle-class children are more likely to pass entrance tests such as the 11-plus, partly because their parents can pay for tutoring and have the cultural capital to prepare them. As a result, grammar schools take very few disadvantaged pupils (only 3% of grammar school pupils were eligible for free school meals in 2019, against 15% elsewhere), so selection gives an advantage to those who are already advantaged.

2. Pupils who are not selected may be labelled as failures. Pupils who fail a selection test at 11 can see themselves, and be seen by teachers, as less able. This can lead to a self-fulfilling prophecy in which they lower their aspirations and achieve less than they could have, even though ability isn’t fixed at 11 and some are simply ‘late developers’.

KT’s Commentary

With only four marks available, each point needs one sentence to name the criticism and one or two to explain it. That’s all. Both points here are criticisms of selection by ability, which is what the question asks. Selection by mortgage or faith would be off the point, however good the sociology.

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle

If you like this sort of thing, then you might like my sociology of education revision notes bundle, written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.

Signposting and Related Posts

This post has been written for students studying the education module as part of AQA A-level sociology. Related posts:

Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com

Sources
  • Department for Education (2021) School Admissions Code, in force 1 September 2021.
  • Department of Education and Science (1965) Circular 10/65, The Organisation of Secondary Education.
  • House of Commons Library (2019) Grammar School Statistics, Briefing Paper 1398.
  • Independent Schools Council (2026) ISC Census and Annual Report 2026.
  • Ministry of Education (1947) The New Secondary Education, Pamphlet No. 9.
  • Tough, S. and Brooks, R. (2007) School Admissions: Fair Choice for Parents and Pupils, Institute for Public Policy Research.

3 thoughts on “Selection Policies in Education”

  1. Pingback: How I Would’ve Answered Yesterday’s AS Sociology Exam Paper (7191/1 – Education) | ReviseSociology

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top