Below is an example of an actual marked response to a 4 mark ‘outline question’, marked by AQA examiners.
The example is taken from the 2017 Crime and Deviance with Theory and Methods Paper (paper and mark schemes available from the AQA website) and the specific question is:
Outline two reasons for ethnic differences in criminal conviction rates (4)
The mark scheme for this question is as below:
Two marks for each of two appropriate reasons clearly outlined or one mark for each appropriate reason partially outlined, such as:
- The police are racist (1 mark); they are less likely to stop and search white people and so they are less likely to detect their offences (+1 mark).
- Some minority ethnic groups are relatively deprived (1 mark); and so they commit more utilitarian crime (+1 mark).
- Ethnic minorities have a younger average age profile (1 mark); and offenders in general are disproportionately young (+1 mark).
- Some ethnic groups are more likely to commit crimes against the person (1 mark); and so they are more likely to be witnessed by victims, identified and caught (+1 mark).
Other relevant material should be credited.
No marks for no relevant points.
While this example is taken from 4 mark outline question from the education paper, the general advice below on how to answer such questions applies equally both the 4 and 6 mark outline questions on both A level sociology papers 3 and 1.
For general advice on how to answer 4 and 6 mark outline questions please see this post here.
Marked exemplar of a 4 mark question:
- The first candidate’s response above is an excellent example of a classic ‘1+1’ strategy…. give a reason and explain HOW this leads to differences.
- Obviously the second response is a good example of ‘how not to do it!’. You need to get yer answers right!
- The candidate could have selected any of the other ‘identifiers’ in the mark scheme above to pick up an additional two marks.
- A-level SOCIOLOGY Feedback on the Examinations Student responses and commentaries: Paper 3 7192/3 Crime and Deviance with Theory and Methods
(Published: Autumn 2017)
- The AQA’s 2017 Paper 3 Sociology (7192/3) Mark Scheme.
NB – the first document is NOT available on the AQA website, but any teacher should have access to it via eaqa. I’m sharing it here in order to make the exam standards more accessible, and to support the AQA in their equality and meritocratic agendas, because there will be some poor students somewhere whose teachers aren’t organised enough to access this material for them.
Leave a Reply