Applying material from Item D and your knowledge, evaluate feminist explanations of the role of the family in society today (20 marks)

Last Updated on November 20, 2026 by Karl Thompson

This is the 20-mark Families question from AQA A-level Sociology Paper 2 (7192/2), June 2019. Below you’ll find the question, what it’s asking you to do, how the marks are split, a plan and a full model answer.

The question

June 2019, Question 06 (20 marks):

“Applying material from Item D and your knowledge, evaluate feminist explanations of the role of the family in society today.”

In summary, Item D sets out the feminist view that the conventional nuclear family is harmful to women and plays a part in their continuing oppression, pointing to three areas: domestic violence, paid employment and power. It then notes that other sociologists reject this negative view and argue that the family is essential for society.

What the question is asking

  • “Feminist explanations” is plural. You need more than one type of feminism, and you get credit for showing how they differ: liberal, Marxist and radical feminism at least.
  • “The role of the family” means what the family does: for women, for men, for children and for society.
  • “Today” matters. Use recent evidence and ask how far feminist arguments from the 1970s still fit.
  • “Applying material from Item D” means picking up the Item’s hooks: domestic violence, paid employment, power, and the counter-view that the family is essential for society. Use them explicitly.
  • “Evaluate” means weighing the explanations against evidence and against other perspectives, then reaching a judgement.

How the marks are split

  • AO1, knowledge and understanding: 8 marks
  • AO2, application (to the Item and to the question): 6 marks
  • AO3, analysis and evaluation: 6 marks

Plan

  1. Introduction: feminists see the family as a site of gender inequality, not harmony; flag the Item’s three areas and its counter-view.
  2. Radical feminism: Millett, Delphy and Leonard; domestic violence from the Item, with Crime Survey evidence. Evaluate: male victims, progress, separatism.
  3. Marxist feminism: Benston, Ansley, the reserve army of labour; paid employment from the Item. Evaluate: patriarchy predates capitalism; employment rates; but motherhood still pushes women out of full-time work.
  4. Liberal feminism: Somerville, progress and policy. Evaluate: the dual burden (ONS time use), and the pay gap opening up around motherhood.
  5. Power, from the Item: Duncombe and Marsden’s triple shift; who becomes the main earner after children.
  6. The counter-view, from the Item: functionalists and the New Right see the family as essential. Feminist reply.
  7. Wider criticisms: difference feminism, postmodernism (Stacey), the personal life perspective (Smart).
  8. Conclusion: a judgement on how far feminist explanations fit the family today.

Model answer

Feminists see the family not as a harmonious institution that benefits everyone, but as one of the main places where gender inequality is produced and reproduced. As Item D suggests, they point to the harm the conventional nuclear family can do to women through domestic violence, women’s position in paid employment and unequal power in couples. However, feminists disagree about why this happens and how much has changed. And, as the Item notes, other sociologists reject this negative picture altogether and see the family as essential for society.

Radical feminists make the strongest claim: that the family is the foundation of patriarchy. Kate Millett (1970) called the family patriarchy’s “chief institution”, because it is where children are socialised into patriarchal ideas about the roles, temperaments and status of men and women. Delphy and Leonard (1992) treat the family as an economic system in which wives do most of the work and husbands gain most of the benefit. Applying the Item, domestic violence is the clearest example of what radical feminists call the dark side of family life. The Crime Survey for England and Wales estimated that 3.8 million people aged 16 and over experienced domestic abuse in the year ending March 2025, about 2.2 million of them women. For radical feminists this is not just the behaviour of a few individual men: it is one way patriarchal power is kept in place.

However, the same survey estimates around 1.5 million male victims, which suggests that abuse within families is not only about men’s power over women. Radical feminism also struggles to explain change. Equal pay legislation, divorce reform and women’s control over their own fertility have given women far more choice than in the 1970s, when much of this theory was written. Its proposed solutions, such as separatism, have little appeal for most women, the great majority of whom still live in heterosexual relationships.

Marxist feminists agree that the family oppresses women, but see capitalism rather than men as the main beneficiary. Margaret Benston (1969) argued that because “women are a group who work outside the money economy”, housework is not treated as real work, even though it reproduces the labour force for free. Fran Ansley (1972) argued that wives absorb the frustration their husbands feel at work, so that it is turned on the family rather than on employers. On this view the role of the family today is to stabilise capitalism. Applying the Item’s reference to paid employment, Marxist feminists also see women as a reserve army of labour, drawn into work when capitalism needs them and pushed out again when it doesn’t.

The obvious criticism, made by radical feminists, is that patriarchy existed long before capitalism, so capitalism can’t be its root cause. The reserve army idea also fits today’s labour market poorly: in June to August 2026 the UK employment rate was 78.3% for men and 72.4% for women, a gap of only about six percentage points. On the other hand, the family still shapes women’s paid work in ways that Marxist feminists would recognise. A study for the Government Equalities Office (Harkness, Borkowska and Pelikh, 2019) found that three years after having a child, only 27.8% of mothers were in full-time work or self-employment, against 90% of fathers.

Liberal feminists such as Jennifer Somerville (2000) give a more optimistic account of the family today. They see inequality as rooted mainly in the public sphere, in unequal pay, stereotyped subject choices and the cost of childcare, and they believe gradual reform is working. Women now have far more choice over marriage, cohabitation, childbearing and relationships, and dual-earner households have made couples more equal. Shared parental leave (for babies due from April 2015) and funded childcare from nine months (for working parents in England, fully in place from September 2025) are the kind of reforms liberal feminists support.

Radical feminists reply that paid work has added a dual burden rather than ending inequality, and the evidence partly supports them. ONS time-use data for autumn 2023 found that women did 3 hours 37 minutes of unpaid work a day, 54 minutes more than men. But that gap had narrowed from 1 hour 12 minutes in 2020, which supports the liberal view that things are improving. The gender pay gap shows the same mixed picture. Among full-time employees it was just 0.3% for 18 to 21 year olds in April 2026, but 8.2% for 40 to 49 year olds, and the ONS says the jump around age 40 is largely explained by the impact of motherhood.

The Item also raises power. Duncombe and Marsden (1995) argue that women work a “triple shift”, adding emotion work (managing the feelings of partners and children) to paid work and housework. That suggests even equal hours of housework would not mean equal relationships. Money is another source of power. In the Government Equalities Office study, the man was the main earner in 54% of couples before the birth of a child, rising to 69% three years afterwards. This supports the feminist view that the family still turns motherhood into economic dependence.

The other sociologists referred to in Item D see the family as essential for society. Functionalists such as Murdock (1949) argued that the nuclear family performs universal functions: sexual, reproductive, economic and educational. Parsons saw the wife’s expressive role as stabilising adult personalities, his “warm bath” theory. Feminists accept that families do these things, but ask who pays for them: the warm bath is exactly what Ansley calls absorbing men’s frustration. New Right writers such as Murray (1984) and Dennis and Erdos (1992) go further, arguing that the decline of the two-parent family, especially families without fathers, harms children and society. Feminists counter that this view ignores the dark side of family life and would push women back into dependence on men. Even so, functionalists and the New Right are right that most people still choose family life: married couples made up 65.3% of UK families in 2025.

There are also wider criticisms of feminist explanations as a group. Difference feminists argue that much second-wave feminism treated women as a single group and reflected the experience of white, middle-class women, so it can’t explain how class and ethnicity shape women’s experience of family life. Postmodernists such as Judith Stacey (1990) found that women were often the ones driving change, leaving unhappy marriages and building new “divorce-extended” families, which suggests women are active agents rather than simply victims of the family. The personal life perspective (Carol Smart, 2007) argues that structural theories, feminism included, impose a single story on very varied relationships instead of starting from what family means to the people in it.

Overall, feminist explanations remain convincing on the evidence that matters most for the family “today”. Women still do more unpaid work, are more likely to be victims of domestic abuse, and become more economically dependent after having children. But the strongest version of the argument is the liberal one. Radical and Marxist feminist accounts struggle to explain how much has changed since the 1970s, and they generalise from some families to all families. The most accurate conclusion is that the family today is less patriarchal than it was but still unequal, and that the inequality is concentrated around motherhood rather than in marriage itself.

Where to find more on each point

A Level Sociology Families and Households Revision Bundle

Revise Families and Households properly

Notes at two depths, so you can start early and finish fast — mid-depth notes to learn and build essay content from, and one-page summary sheets for the last fortnight.

Families and Households Revision Bundle, AQA A-level Sociology Paper 2

Families and Households
70 pages of mid-depth notes, 20 colour At a Glance sheets, 14 mind maps and 12 exam questions with model answers, including nine full essay plans. New for 2026.

A-Level Sociology Revision Mega Bundle, all six modules

Or take all six modules
Families plus Education, Beliefs, the Media, Crime and Deviance, and Theory and Methods. Over 450 pages, 110 sheets, 71 mind maps and 88 exam questions. Bought separately they come to more than £35.

Written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.

Sources
  • AQA A-level Sociology Paper 2 (7192/2), June 2019, Question 06. The question is reproduced with acknowledgement to AQA.
  • Delphy, C. and Leonard, D. (1992) Familiar Exploitation. Polity Press.
  • Duncombe, J. and Marsden, D. (1995) ‘Workaholics’ and ‘whingeing women’: theorising intimacy and emotion work. The Sociological Review.
  • Harkness, S., Borkowska, M. and Pelikh, A. (2019) Employment pathways and occupational change after childbirth. Government Equalities Office.
  • Millett, K. (1970) Sexual Politics.
  • Smart, C. (2007) Personal Life. Polity Press.
  • Somerville, J. (2000) Feminism and the Family. Macmillan.
  • Stacey, J. (1990) Brave New Families. Basic Books.
  • ONS: Domestic abuse in England and Wales overview, November 2025; Labour market overview, UK, October 2026; Time use in the UK, September 2023; Gender pay gap in the UK, 2026; Families and households in the UK, 2025.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top