This question appeared in a recent AQA A-level sociology paper, The Education with Theory and Methods paper.
This post considers the question, mark scheme and then suggests a top and middle band answer.
Top band answers should address all of ethnicity, gender and class in terms of educational achievement.
EXAM QUESTION
Read Item B below and answer the question that follows.
Item B There are differences in patterns of educational achievement between groups of pupils. These differences can be based on class, gender or ethnicity, or a combination of these. Some sociologists argue that cultural factors are the main explanation for differences in educational achievement. Differences in primary socialisation may mean that some groups find it easier to engage with the culture of the school. However, other sociologists argue that material factors, such as access to resources, are also important.
Applying material from Item B and your knowledge, evaluate the importance of cultural factors in explaining patterns of educational achievement [30 marks]
—
Mark Scheme
Top Band
Answers in this band will show sound, conceptually detailed knowledge of a range of relevant material. This knowledge will include the importance of cultural factors in explaining patterns of educational achievement. Sophisticated understanding of the question and of the presented material will be shown. Appropriate material will be applied accurately and with sensitivity to the issues raised by the question. Analysis and evaluation will be explicit and relevant. Evaluation may be developed. For example, a debate can occur between different perspectives such as functionalism, Marxism, feminisms, interactionism, and the New Right. Alternatively, one can examine how cultural and material factors are important. One can also explore how these factors interrelate in explaining patterns of educational achievement. Analysis will show a clear explanation. Appropriate conclusions will be drawn.
Middle Band
Answers in this band will show largely accurate knowledge but limited range and depth, eg a broadly accurate, if basic, account of some ways that cultural factors explain patterns of educational achievement. Understands some limited but significant aspects of the question; superficial understanding of the presented material. Applying listed material from the general topic area but with limited regard for its relevance to the issues raised by the question, or applying a narrow range of more relevant material. Evaluation will take the form of juxtaposition of competing positions or one or two isolated stated points. Analysis will be limited, with answers tending towards the descriptive.
Top Band Answer: Evaluating the Importance of Cultural Factors in Educational Achievement
Educational achievement varies across different social groups, with differences observed based on class, gender, and ethnicity. Some sociologists argue that cultural factors primarily explain these differences. They shape students’ attitudes, values, and engagement with education. Others, however, emphasize the role of material factors, such as economic deprivation and access to resources. This essay will evaluate the importance of cultural factors in explaining educational achievement. It will also consider the role of material factors. Furthermore, it will examine their interrelation.
The Role of Cultural Factors
Cultural factors refer to the norms, values, and practices that influence students’ attitudes towards education. Cultural capital, cultural deprivation, and differing socialization processes all contribute to patterns of achievement.
Cultural Deprivation Theory
Cultural deprivation theorists argue that working-class children underachieve because they lack the cultural resources necessary for educational success. Bernstein (1971) identified differences in speech codes. Middle-class children use the elaborated code. This aligns with the language of the school. Working-class children tend to use the restricted code. This limits their ability to engage fully with academic content. Similarly, Douglas (1964) found that working-class parents placed less emphasis on educational achievement. They were also less involved in their children’s schooling. This led to lower attainment levels (Revisesociology, 2014).
Cultural Capital
Bourdieu (1984) introduced the concept of cultural capital. He argued that middle-class students benefit from the knowledge, skills, and experiences. These align with the education system. Middle-class parents are more likely to engage in cultural activities, such as museum visits. They also favor reading. These activities enhance their children’s intellectual development. Research supports the idea that middle-class students use their cultural capital to navigate the education system more effectively than their working-class peers (Revisesociology, 2015).
Ethnicity and Cultural Attitudes to Education
Ethnic differences in educational achievement can also be explained by cultural factors. Research suggests that Chinese and Indian students often achieve high academic results. This is due to strong parental expectations and a work ethic emphasizing discipline and perseverance. In contrast, some Black Caribbean students may experience conflicts between their home culture and school expectations, contributing to underachievement (Revisesociology, 2015).
The Role of Material Factors
While cultural explanations are significant, material factors also play a crucial role in shaping educational outcomes.
Social Class and Economic Capital
Material deprivation affects access to educational resources, such as private tutoring, high-quality schools, and extracurricular activities. According to government statistics, students from lower socio-economic backgrounds consistently achieve lower GCSE grades than their wealthier peers (Revisesociology, 2020).
Gender and Educational Inequality
While girls now outperform boys at most educational levels, gender disparities remain in subject choices and career aspirations. Socialization processes encourage girls to be more diligent and compliant, contributing to their academic success. However, boys may be influenced by laddish subcultures that devalue academic effort (Revisesociology, 2020).
Interaction Between Cultural and Material Factors
Cultural and material factors often interact, reinforcing educational inequalities. Working-class students may lack financial means. They may also lack cultural capital to access high-achieving schools or engage with enrichment activities. Similarly, ethnic minority students from economically disadvantaged backgrounds may face additional challenges, such as institutional racism and lower teacher expectations (Revisesociology, 2020).
Conclusion
Cultural factors play a significant role in explaining educational achievement. This occurs particularly through differences in cultural capital, socialization, and attitudes toward education. However, material factors cannot be ignored, as economic deprivation significantly impacts students’ access to educational opportunities. A comprehensive understanding of educational inequality must consider the interplay between cultural and material influences.
Middle Band Answer: Evaluating the Importance of Cultural Factors in Educational Achievement
Educational achievement differs among students based on class, gender, and ethnicity. Some sociologists believe that cultural factors are the main reason for these differences, while others argue that material factors, like poverty, are also important. This essay will examine the role of cultural factors in educational achievement and consider the impact of material factors.
Cultural Factors and Education
Cultural factors refer to how children are brought up and what values they are taught at home. Some sociologists argue that differences in upbringing affect how well students do in school.
Cultural Deprivation
Cultural deprivation theory suggests that some working-class children do not have the skills or knowledge that help them succeed in school. Bernstein (1971) identified two speech codes: the elaborated code, used by the middle class and schools, and the restricted code, used by the working class. Because the school system favors the elaborated code, working-class students may struggle to succeed (Revisesociology, 2014).
Cultural Capital
Bourdieu (1984) argued that middle-class students have cultural capital, meaning they have experiences and knowledge that help them do well in school. For example, middle-class parents are more likely to take their children to museums and encourage reading at home, which helps their academic success (Revisesociology, 2015).
Ethnicity and Cultural Differences
Different ethnic groups have different cultural attitudes towards education. Chinese and Indian families often place a high value on education, which can help explain why their children perform well in school. On the other hand, Black Caribbean students may experience cultural clashes with the school system, which can contribute to lower achievement levels (Revisesociology, 2015).
Material Factors
Although cultural factors are important, material factors also impact educational achievement. For example, students from poorer families may not have access to resources like private tutors, a quiet study space, or good schools. Statistics show that students from low-income backgrounds generally achieve lower grades than wealthier students (Revisesociology, 2020).
Conclusion
Cultural factors such as speech codes and parental attitudes play a key role in educational achievement. However, material factors also have a strong influence. A full explanation of educational differences must consider both cultural and economic factors.