Are schools institutionally racist?

Last Updated on October 27, 2026 by Karl Thompson

One sociological explanation for differences in educational achievement by ethnicity is that schools are institutionally racist.

This means that racism is built into the way the school system works: schools are organised in ways that systematically disadvantage children from some ethnic minority backgrounds compared with white children, even if no individual teacher intends it.

If schools are institutionally racist, we should find evidence of it at every level of school organisation: in the way head teachers run schools, in the way teachers interact with pupils, and in government policy and inspection.

This post sets out the evidence for and against, and is part of the sociology of education module, examined on AQA Paper 1 (7192/1).

What is institutional racism?

The best-known definition comes from the Macpherson Report (1999), the inquiry into the police investigation of the murder of Stephen Lawrence:

“The collective failure of an organisation to provide an appropriate and professional service to people because of their colour, culture, or ethnic origin. It can be seen or detected in processes, attitudes and behaviour which amount to discrimination through unwitting prejudice, ignorance, thoughtlessness and racist stereotyping which disadvantage minority ethnic people.”

The key word is ‘unwitting’. Institutional racism doesn’t require anyone to be deliberately racist. It is about outcomes: if an organisation’s routines consistently disadvantage minority ethnic groups, that counts.

What might institutional racism in schools look like?

There are several places we might look to investigate whether schools are institutionally racist:

  • The curriculum might be ethnocentric: the way some subjects are taught, or the way the school year is organised, may make children from some ethnic backgrounds feel left out.
  • School behaviour and exclusion policies might be biased against the cultural practices of pupils from particular ethnic backgrounds.
  • Schools might deal with racist incidents ineffectively, so victims get no redress.
  • Teachers might have different expectations of different ethnic groups, and treat pupils differently as a result.
  • Setting and streaming might place pupils from some minority ethnic groups in lower sets more often than their ability justifies.

Below is some of the evidence on each.

Exclusions by ethnicity

Some minority ethnic groups are much more likely to be permanently excluded from school than others:

Ethnic groupPermanent exclusions per 100 pupils
Gypsy/Roma0.43
Irish Traveller0.35
Mixed White and Black Caribbean0.24
Black Caribbean0.18
White British0.13
All pupils0.11
Black African0.06
Indian0.01
Chinese0.01

State-funded schools in England, 2022/23. Source: Ethnicity facts and figures, Permanent exclusions, published 11 December 2024. Rates for small groups are less reliable.

So Gypsy/Roma pupils are excluded at more than three times the rate of White British pupils, and Mixed White and Black Caribbean pupils at almost twice the rate. Whether this reflects institutional racism is open to interpretation and needs further investigation. Notice, though, that Black African, Indian and Chinese pupils are excluded much less often than White British pupils, so exclusion isn’t higher for minority groups in general. For more on exclusions, see why do some children get excluded from school?

Uniform and hairstyle rules

Some campaigners argue that strict behaviour and uniform policies can penalise Black pupils for cultural practices, such as particular hairstyles. The government has accepted that this is a risk: in 2022 it issued guidance on inclusive uniform policies and said it would work with schools on a resource about pupils’ hairstyles, to avoid indirect discrimination. Supporters of strict policies argue that the same rules for everyone are the fairest approach. This is a good example of the debate about institutional racism: a rule that applies to everyone equally can still have unequal effects.

Adultification and exclusions

In 2022, the Commission on Young Lives, chaired by former Children’s Commissioner Anne Longfield, published All Together Now: Inclusion not exclusion, a report on school exclusions. It noted a rise in permanent exclusions in the decade before the pandemic, from 5,082 in 2010/11 to 7,894 in 2018/19, and said that Black children were more likely to be excluded.

One explanation the report highlighted was the ‘adultification’ of Black children, where Black children are viewed as ‘less innocent’ and more adult-like than other children of the same age. In Longfield’s words, “Essentially, it’s young people being viewed as older.” If teachers and other adults see Black children as older and more responsible for their actions, it can make harsher punishments, such as exclusion, seem justified.

The same idea was central to the Child Q review, also published in 2022. It investigated the strip search of a Black secondary school girl by police officers on school premises in Hackney in 2020; no drugs were found. The review, by the City and Hackney Safeguarding Children Partnership, described adultification bias as a bias in which Black and other minoritised children are seen as more ‘streetwise’ and ‘viewed primarily as a threat rather than as a child who needs support’. It concluded that racism, ‘whether deliberate or not’, was likely to have been an influencing factor.

Adultification links directly to labelling theory: it is a stereotype that shapes how adults respond to children’s behaviour. It’s useful for showing that the labelling of Black pupils is not just a feature of 1980s and 1990s studies such as Wright and Gillborn.

Setting and the A-to-C economy

David Gillborn and Deborah Youdell argued that schools’ focus on league tables created an ‘A-to-C economy’, in which schools concentrated their efforts on pupils judged able to get a C grade. They called the sorting process ‘educational triage’. Teachers were more likely to judge Black pupils as having less ability: in one school, only 2 Black pupils (5.6% of Black pupils) were in the top ability band, compared with 99 white pupils (33.2%).

Because this disadvantage comes from the way schools respond to policy and routine, not from individual prejudice, Gillborn sees it as institutional racism. The study is covered in full on Gillborn and Youdell: rationing education.

More recent national data supports the general point. Steve Strand (2012) found that Black Caribbean pupils were less likely to be entered for higher-tier tests at age 14 than White British pupils with the same prior attainment and family background.

Gillborn: critical race theory

David Gillborn is the sociologist most associated with the argument that English education is institutionally racist. In Racism and Education: Coincidence or Conspiracy? (2008), he applied critical race theory (CRT) to English schools.

CRT starts from the idea that racism is not unusual or accidental but a normal, everyday feature of society, built into its institutions. Gillborn argued that:

  • The achievement gap between Black and White pupils in England has the hallmarks of ‘locked-in inequality’: an inequality so great and so deep-seated that the normal workings of the system can’t close it.
  • Policies that look neutral can still benefit White pupils. He criticised the Gifted and Talented programme, for example, for increasing selection within schools; it received millions of pounds of extra funding and was dominated by middle-class pupils.
  • The answer to his book’s title, coincidence or conspiracy, is that it isn’t a deliberate plot by individuals. But policies and institutions keep producing the same unequal outcomes, and keep protecting White advantage, as if it were.

Evaluation: critics argue that CRT treats all inequality between ethnic groups as evidence of racism, and that it can’t easily explain why many minority groups, such as Chinese, Indian and Black African pupils, now do better than White British pupils. Gillborn’s focus is mainly on the Black/White gap, where the evidence for school factors is strongest.

Education policy and Prevent

Gillborn and others argue that education policy has done little to combat racism over several decades. See policies to combat racism in schools.

Since 2015, schools have had a legal duty, the Prevent duty, to help prevent young people being drawn into terrorism. Critics, such as the Open Society Justice Initiative in its 2016 report Eroding Trust, argue that Prevent in schools damages trust between teachers and pupils and between the state and the Muslim community. A 2019 review of 27 studies by Jerome, Elwick and Kazim found that the policy was often read through Islamophobic discourses and seemed to be generating unintended negative side effects.

HOWEVER, the statistics don’t support the claim that Prevent is mostly about Muslims. In 2024/25, education made more referrals than any other sector (36%), but only 10% of all referrals concerned Islamist extremism, while 21% concerned extreme right-wing extremism and over half involved no clear ideology. Prevent doesn’t record religion. Of referrals where ethnicity was recorded, 65% were White. The debate is covered on the Prevent agenda: arguments for and against.

Racist incidents in schools

We have only partial data on racism in schools. According to a 2021 Guardian investigation based on freedom of information requests, UK schools recorded more than 60,000 racist incidents over five years. That is likely to be an underestimate, because there is no national system for collecting this data.

Pupils’ experiences of racism

A 2020 YMCA survey of 557 young Black and mixed-ethnicity people aged 16 to 30, Young and Black, found that 95% had heard or witnessed racist language at school. Half said teachers’ perceptions of them were the biggest barrier to their educational success, and 49% said racism was the biggest barrier to their academic attainment.

Gypsy, Roma and Traveller pupils

In 2018, Professor Kalwant Bhopal told a parliamentary committee that Gypsy, Roma and Traveller pupils faced discrimination in school from both peers and teachers. When they reported racism, she said, it often wasn’t recognised as racism ‘because they’re white groups’, and the curriculum ‘does not represent adequately Gypsy, Roma and Traveller histories’. See Gypsy, Roma and Traveller pupils.

Evaluation: are schools institutionally racist?

Evidence for:

  • Some groups, especially Gypsy/Roma, Irish Traveller and Mixed White and Black Caribbean pupils, are excluded far more often than White British pupils.
  • Black Caribbean pupils are entered for lower tiers than similar White British pupils (Strand 2012), and studies such as Gillborn and Youdell find Black pupils placed in lower sets than their ability justifies.
  • Reviews such as Child Q and the Commission on Young Lives identify adultification bias in how Black children are treated.
  • Many Black young people report experiencing racism at school.

Evidence against:

  • Most minority ethnic groups now achieve better results than White British pupils in the same schools. If schools were institutionally racist against minorities in general, this would be hard to explain.
  • Black African, Indian and Chinese pupils are excluded less often than White British pupils.
  • The 2021 Commission on Race and Ethnic Disparities argued that the term ‘institutional racism’ should only be used where deep-seated racism can be proven at a systemic level, and that factors such as family and class explained many disparities. Its report was itself strongly criticised.
  • Survey evidence of experiences of racism is important, but it measures perceptions, and samples like the YMCA’s are not necessarily representative.

Conclusion: are schools ‘institutionally racist’?

The evidence is strongest for particular groups and particular processes, rather than for minorities as a whole. There is good evidence that Black Caribbean, Mixed White and Black Caribbean and Gypsy, Roma and Traveller pupils are disadvantaged by school processes such as exclusion, setting and tiering, and that stereotypes such as adultification play a part. But the high achievement of many minority groups means that institutional racism can’t explain the overall pattern of ethnic differences on its own. In an exam, the strongest answers distinguish between groups rather than treating ‘ethnic minorities’ as one.

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle

If you like this sort of thing, then you might like my sociology of education revision notes bundle, written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.

Signposting

This material is mainly relevant to the sociology of education, usually taught in the first year of A-level Sociology. Institutional racism is one ‘in-school factor’, alongside teacher labelling and pupil subcultures, covered on ethnicity and educational achievement: in-school factors.

Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com

Sources
  • Macpherson, W. (1999) The Stephen Lawrence Inquiry, para. 6.34.
  • Commission on Young Lives (2022) All Together Now: Inclusion not exclusion: supporting all young people to succeed in school.
  • City and Hackney Safeguarding Children Partnership (2022) Local Child Safeguarding Practice Review: Child Q.
  • Department for Education (2022) ‘How we’re helping to make sure people from all backgrounds are supported in the education system’ (17 March 2022).
  • Gillborn, D. (2008) Racism and Education: Coincidence or Conspiracy? London: Routledge.
  • Gillborn, D. and Youdell, D. (2000) Rationing Education.
  • Strand, S. (2012) ‘The White British–Black Caribbean achievement gap’, British Educational Research Journal, 38(1).
  • Home Office (2025) Individuals referred to and supported through the Prevent programme, April 2024 to March 2025 (6 November 2025).
  • Open Society Justice Initiative (2016) Eroding Trust: The UK’s Prevent Counter-Extremism Strategy in Health and Education.
  • Jerome, L., Elwick, A. and Kazim, R. (2019) ‘The impact of the Prevent duty on schools: a review of the evidence’, British Educational Research Journal, 45(4).
  • The Guardian (28 March 2021) ‘UK schools record more than 60,000 racist incidents in five years’.
  • YMCA (2020) Young and Black: The Young Black Experience of Institutional Racism in the UK.
  • Commission on Race and Ethnic Disparities (2021) The Report.
  • Ethnicity facts and figures (2024) Permanent exclusions, 2022 to 2023.

Pre-update graphs…..

Source: Pupil Exclusions, published January 2020

Exclusion Rates for Black Caribbean Children

2 thoughts on “Are schools institutionally racist?”

  1. The evidence is open to interpretation… conclusion based mainly on the fact that schools seem to haven effective measures in place to deal with reported overt racism.

  2. They are NOT?
    I don’t understand. All of the evidence that you cite above gives clear examples of how schools and Education and an institution have policies and practices which specifically disadvantage students (and staff) from ‘minority’ groups.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top