Free Schools – Arguments and Evidence For and Against

Last Updated on November 5, 2026 by Karl Thompson

Free schools are brand-new state schools, set up by groups such as parents, teachers, charities and faith groups, and run as academies. They were the Coalition government’s flagship schools policy, and they’re a good example of the marketisation of education: more providers, more choice, and less control by local authorities.

This post covers what free schools are, how they differ from academies and local authority schools, their history, the evidence on how they’ve done, and the arguments for and against them. It’s relevant to the education policy topic in the sociology of education (AQA Paper 1, 7192/1), and especially useful for evaluating Coalition and New Right policies.

What are free schools?

A free school in England is a type of academy: a non-profit, state-funded school which is free to attend. It isn’t controlled by the local authority but is run by an academy trust, a charitable company that gets its funding directly from central government.

To set up a free school, a group applies to the Department for Education (DfE). Groups have included parents, teachers, education charities, existing academy trusts and religious groups. Once open, a free school is funded on the same basis as other state schools, though the DfE also pays start-up costs, including buying land and buildings.

Free schools are an England-only policy: there are none in Wales, Scotland or Northern Ireland.

Types of free school

Most free schools are ordinary primary or secondary schools. Two distinctive kinds are:

  • University technical colleges (UTCs): for 14–18 year olds, specialising in technical and employment-focused subjects, sponsored by a university, employer or further education college.
  • Studio schools: small schools, usually of around 300 pupils, using project-based learning.

Free schools and academies: what’s the difference?

Legally, there isn’t one: a free school is an academy. The difference is how the school came about.

Free schoolAcademy (converter or sponsored)
How it startsA brand-new school, where there wasn’t one beforeAn existing school that converts, or is taken over by a sponsor
Who proposes itA group that applies to the DfE: parents, teachers, charities, faith groups, trustsThe school’s own governors (converter), or the DfE after a poor Ofsted judgement (sponsored)
Legal status and freedomsThe same: run by an academy trust, funded directly by central government, outside local authority control

For academies more generally, see my post on academies in England.

Free schools compared with local authority schools

Similarities

  • Both are free for pupils to attend.
  • Both are funded on a similar basis per pupil.
  • Both follow similar rules on admissions.
  • Both are inspected by Ofsted.

Differences

Local authority schoolsFree schools
FundingThrough the local authorityDirectly from central government
CurriculumMust follow the national curriculumDon’t have to, for now. Under the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 they’ll have to teach the new national curriculum, expected from September 2028
School day and term datesSet by the local authoritySet by the trust
Teachers’ qualificationsTeachers must have qualified teacher status (QTS)Can employ teachers without QTS. From 1 September 2027 new teachers must have, or be working towards, QTS
Teachers’ payNational pay and conditionsSet by the trust until now; the 2026 Act brings all state school teachers under one core framework

So the 2026 Act narrows the gap between free schools and other state schools. More on the Act in my post on Labour education policy since 2024.

A brief history of free schools

The Coalition (2010–2015)

Free schools were introduced by the Coalition under the Academies Act 2010, championed by the Education Secretary Michael Gove. The first 24 opened in September 2011. By September 2014 the government said it had opened more than 250, and by September 2016 the number had reached 425 (House of Commons Library).

The Conservatives (2015–2024)

Free schools kept opening after 2015 and became the main way new state schools were created. Until the 2026 Act, local authorities couldn’t open new schools of their own: a new school had to be an academy or a free school.

Labour (2024 onwards)

Labour has changed course in two ways:

  • A review of planned free schools. In October 2024 the Education Secretary, Bridget Phillipson, announced a review of 44 centrally approved mainstream free school projects that hadn’t yet opened, looking at whether each would meet a need for places and give value for money. In December 2025 the DfE said 16 would go ahead and 28 were ‘minded to cancel’, subject to appeal, with the money redirected towards places for pupils with special educational needs.
  • Councils can open schools again. The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 lets local authorities open any type of school, not only academies and free schools.

The evidence on free schools

The Education Policy Institute (2019)

The EPI’s Free schools in England: 2019 report looked at where free schools had opened and how they performed:

  • Places where they’re needed: primary free schools did better than secondaries at creating places where they were needed. In the areas with the greatest need for places, primary free schools added 11 places per 1,000 pupils, but secondary free schools just 4. Secondary free schools added more places in areas that already had spare capacity, and more in high-performing areas (17.7 per 1,000) than low-performing ones (4.5).
  • Who attends: nearly half of secondary free school pupils came from three types of community (inner-city cosmopolitan, urban cultural mix, and young ethnic communities). Two other deprived types, which the ONS calls ‘hampered neighbourhoods’ and ‘challenged white communities’, were under-served.
  • Results: secondary free schools had the highest Progress 8 scores of any type of school (+0.24, or +0.12 once pupil characteristics are taken into account). Primary free schools had lower attainment than every other type except sponsored academies.
  • Popularity with parents: free schools were the least likely type of school to be a family’s first preference: about a fifth of primary applicants and a quarter of secondary applicants put one first.

The National Audit Office (2017)

The NAO found that the 175 sites the DfE had bought for free schools cost an average of £4.9 million each, with 24 costing over £10 million and four over £30 million. It said free schools were playing ‘an increasingly important role’ in providing new places, but that ‘in some areas… free schools are creating spare capacity which may have implications for schools’ financial sustainability’.

Free Schools: Arguments for and against

infographic summarising arguments for and against FREE SCHOOLS created for A-level sociology.

Arguments for free schools

Free schools are a very good example of a neoliberal policy: the government takes power away from local authorities (local government) and gives more power to parents, charities, trusts and other groups to run schools.

Supporters claim that:

  • Competition drives up standards. New schools give parents an alternative, so existing schools have to improve. The strong Progress 8 scores of secondary free schools are their best evidence.
  • They give parents more choice in the type of education their child receives, much as parents who can afford private schools already have.
  • They create school places, especially at primary level, where the EPI found they mostly opened where places were needed.

Arguments against free schools

Critics argue that:

  • They benefit mainly middle-class parents, who have the time, confidence and contacts to set them up, which can increase social segregation. I can really see this being the case with studio schools. (I can’t help but imagine a nice, small school with extensive playground and playing fields in a Devonshire village, so nice in fact that the yummies occasionally leave their 4WDs at home and walk the school run, at least when they’re not in the mood for heels.) The EPI’s finding that some deprived communities are under-served fits this concern.
  • They divert money from existing schools. The education budget is limited, so land, buildings and start-up grants for free schools leave relatively less for others. The NAO’s figures on land costs show how much was involved.
  • They aren’t always needed. Secondary free schools in particular often opened where there were already enough places, creating spare capacity that can leave nearby schools short of pupils and money (EPI, NAO).
  • Parents don’t seem to prefer them. They were the least likely type of school to be a first preference (EPI).
  • They weaken local planning. With new schools decided centrally, councils lost much of their role in planning school places for their area. Labour’s review of the pipeline and the 2026 Act’s return of councils’ power to open schools can be read as a response to this.

How free schools come up in the exam

Free schools are useful in Paper 1 questions on marketisation, diversity and choice. For example:

  • AQA June 2022, Question 04: “Applying material from Item B and your knowledge, evaluate the view that marketisation policies have increased diversity and choice in the education system.” [30 marks]. Free schools increase diversity of provision, but the EPI’s findings on location and parental preference let you question how much real choice they offer, and to whom.
  • AQA June 2023, Question 02: “Outline three criticisms of marketisation policies in education.” [6 marks]

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle

If you like this sort of thing, then you might like my sociology of education revision notes bundle, written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.

Signposting and Related Posts

Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com

Sources
  • Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026; DfE Education Hub (2026) ‘The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act: what parents need to know’, 12 May 2026; National Governance Association, ‘From the Commons to the classroom’, 30 April 2026.
  • Department for Education (2014) ‘Unprecedented number of new schools opened since 2010’, 1 September 2014.
  • Education Policy Institute (2019) Free schools in England: 2019 report, as summarised by Schools Week.
  • House of Commons Library (2016) Free schools in England, Briefing Paper 7033, 2 December 2016.
  • National Audit Office (2017) Capital funding for schools, 22 February 2017.
  • Phillipson, B. (2024) written ministerial statement on the free schools pipeline, 22 October 2024; Schools Week (December 2025) on the outcome of the review.

1 thought on “Free Schools – Arguments and Evidence For and Against”

  1. Pingback: The Education System in England and Wales – ReviseSociology

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top