Applying material from Item A, analyse two effects of increased parental choice on pupils’ experience of education.

Last Updated on November 5, 2026 by Karl Thompson

This is Question 03 from AQA A-level Sociology Paper 1 (7192/1), June 2017: the 10-mark ‘analyse with the item’ question on education. Below are the item, the mark scheme levels, the two hooks, and a model answer, with notes on why it would score in the top band.

For how to approach these questions in general, and a real answer marked by AQA’s examiners (5/10) for this same question, see my guide to the 10-mark analyse question.

The question

A-level-sociology-10-mark-question-parental-choice

Read Item A below and answer the question that follows.

Item A

Since the 1980s, a major aim of government policy has been to increase parental choice in education. There is now a wider range of school types, and league tables on school performance are also publicly available.

Increased parental choice has had many effects on pupils’ experience of education.

Applying material from Item A, analyse two effects of increased parental choice on pupils’ experience of education. [10 marks]

Source: AQA, A-level Sociology Paper 1 (7192/1), June 2017. Past papers and mark schemes are on AQA’s website.

The mark scheme

A-level-sociology-10-mark-scheme-top-band

8–10 Answers in this band will show good knowledge and understanding of relevant material on two effects of increased parental choice on pupils’ experience of education.

There will be two developed applications of material from the item, eg increased pressure on pupils to improve the school’s league table position; different types of school offer a different curriculum to their pupils.

There will be appropriate analysis/evaluation of two effects, eg existence of different types of school may accentuate social class differences in opportunities available to pupils; not all parents are equally able to exercise choice of school and how this affects pupils’ experience.

4–7 Answers in this band will show a basic to reasonable knowledge and understanding of one to two effects of increased parental choice on pupils’ experience of education.

There will be some successful application of material from the item, eg how parents can choose a school for their children that reflects their religious or cultural preference; how league tables may force pupils to study particular subjects.

There will be some analysis/evaluation.

1–3 Answers in this band will show limited knowledge and understanding of one to two effects of increased parental choice on pupils’ experience of education.

There will be limited application of material from the item. Some material may be at a tangent to the question, eg on schools selecting pupils.

There will be limited or no analysis/evaluation.

0 No relevant points.

Sources may include the following or other relevant ones: Chubb and Moe, Ball, Whitty, David, Gewirtz, Thompson, Trowler, Bartlett.

The two hooks

Both hooks are in the first paragraph of the item:

  1. ‘A wider range of school types’: academies, free schools, faith schools, grammar schools and so on.
  2. ‘League tables on school performance are also publicly available’.

Each hook is one paragraph. Notice the question is about pupils’ experience, not about parents or schools. Every paragraph has to end up with what happens to pupils.

Model answer

Item A says there is now ‘a wider range of school types’, such as academies, free schools and faith schools, which parents can choose between. One effect on pupils is that different types of school offer pupils different curricula and ethos. An academy might specialise in a subject, a faith school will include religious education and worship, and since academies haven’t had to follow the national curriculum, pupils in different schools may study quite different things. New Right thinkers such as Chubb and Moe would see this as positive: competition between different types of school drives up standards and lets pupils go to a school that suits them. HOWEVER, the pupils who get into the most popular schools are disproportionately middle class. Gewirtz found that middle-class ‘skilled choosers’ had the cultural capital to research schools, understand admissions and appeal if refused, while working-class ‘disconnected choosers’ tended to pick the nearest school. Popular schools also tend to be in more expensive areas, so some parents can buy their way into a catchment area. So the wider range of schools may accentuate class differences: middle-class pupils experience the better-resourced, oversubscribed schools, while working-class pupils are more likely to end up in the schools no one chose. And not all parents have real choice at all: in rural areas there may be only one school within reach.

Item A also says that ‘league tables on school performance are also publicly available’, so parents can compare schools’ results. Because schools’ popularity, and so their funding, depends on their position, schools come under pressure to improve their results, and that pressure is passed on to pupils. Gillborn and Youdell found that schools practised ‘educational triage’, concentrating effort on pupils just below the grade C borderline, who could lift the school’s headline figures, while pupils seen as hopeless cases got less attention. Pupils may experience more testing, more revision sessions and more ‘teaching to the test’, and may be steered into subjects or courses that help the school’s results rather than their own interests. Bartlett argued that league tables encourage ‘cream-skimming’, where schools try to attract the most able pupils, and ‘silt-shifting’, where they try to avoid pupils likely to bring results down, such as those with special educational needs. HOWEVER, supporters argue that league tables make schools accountable and push them to improve teaching for all pupils, and Progress 8, which measures progress across eight subjects rather than the share of pupils passing a grade threshold, gives schools less reason to focus only on borderline pupils.

Why this would score in the top band

  • Two developed applications, each starting with a quotation from the item, one per paragraph.
  • Each paragraph is about pupils’ experience, not just about parents or schools.
  • Analysis and evaluation in both paragraphs: the first weighs the New Right view against class inequality in choice; the second weighs the pressure of league tables against the accountability argument.
  • Sociologists from the mark scheme’s list (Chubb and Moe, Gewirtz, Bartlett), plus Gillborn and Youdell, used to support points rather than just named.
  • Balanced length: the second paragraph is as developed as the first, which is where most answers lose marks.

KT’s commentary: the trick with this one is to keep dragging it back to pupils. The item is about parental choice, so it’s very easy to write two paragraphs about middle-class parents and never say what happens to the kids. Every paragraph should end with what the pupil experiences.

Examiner report

I haven’t included points from AQA’s examiner report for this paper. If you’re a teacher, AQA’s report on the June 2017 Paper 1 is worth reading alongside this.

Related posts

Sociology of Education Revision Bundle

If you like this sort of thing, then you might like my sociology of education revision notes bundle, written by Karl Thompson, who taught A-level sociology for eighteen years and spent twelve as an AQA examiner, marking all three papers on the current specification.

Please click here to return to the homepage – ReviseSociology.com

2 thoughts on “Applying material from Item A, analyse two effects of increased parental choice on pupils’ experience of education.”

  1. you are amazing, thanks for caring about disadvantaged pupils, this website has helped me alot <3

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top